| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. 08:36 - Apr 24 with 8356 views | merovingian |
True or false?
What club missing since promotion is the tenacity & willingness to go 100% in each match. Ability to adapt & self belief. |  |
| |  |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 08:42 - Apr 24 with 5375 views | stuabd |
One training session with PDC and most of our lot would have come down with shoulder/arm/ankle soreness and would have declared themselves unfit to play. A couple would have just got the hump and gone home.
Nope, I don't think he would have saved us. [Post edited 1 Jan 1970 1:00]
|  | | |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 08:43 - Apr 24 with 5366 views | ElHoop |
Nobody could save that particular set of players from a position of four points from 13 games. Even Clough would have struggled. |  | | |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 08:44 - Apr 24 with 5365 views | Vish |
False.
Even if we went all out attacking, our defence is frail and some of the players are not interested in putting in a shift. Nothing Di Canio could have done about that. |  | | |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 08:48 - Apr 24 with 5359 views | Neil_SI |
I'm not sure.
I think he suited Sunderland, because it was largely a settled team that just lacked a bit of inspiration and motivation.
De Canio has proved he can revitalise clubs, but, our dressing room and club is fraught and fractured. Bringing him in at this point may have caused him to further ruffle too many feathers during the season, which may or may not have been counter productive.
I'd have a different view had he been in the hot seat during the off season and pre-season, as his galvanising effect would carry more weight if he would be able to offload those who don't buy into his way of doing things.
But we're a tough club that finds out many and demands the absolute best from its managers, so we really can only do one of two; either employ somebody with the right character, personality and experience (such as a Neil Warnock or a Harry Redknapp) to steady the ship and start moving it forward... or give enough time to a younger manager who has a long term vision from top to bottom, but that requires patience and time from everybody.
The problem is, we have shown over the years a lack of patience, both from the owners to the fans. A change in philosophy and mentality is needed, but whether the time afforded to do that is granted, is another matter entirely.
The lack of experience becomes a problem if there is no patience in a long term vision, so a younger manage has less of a chance to improve the foundations that would really allow us to prosper as a club.
|  | | |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 08:49 - Apr 24 with 5353 views | JonDoeman |
Might have been more fun!  |  |
| |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 08:51 - Apr 24 with 5347 views | BrianMcCarthy |
Some things are not worth it. He's a fascist, and him walking through the door would be our lowest moment yet. |  |
| |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 08:55 - Apr 24 with 5329 views | PlumsteadQPR |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 08:51 - Apr 24 by BrianMcCarthy |
Some things are not worth it. He's a fascist, and him walking through the door would be our lowest moment yet. |
This. |  | | |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 08:56 - Apr 24 with 5320 views | Ranger78 |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 08:55 - Apr 24 by PlumsteadQPR |
This. |
I'm with you |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 09:08 - Apr 24 with 5307 views | Monahoop |
Despite the mess he inherited, Redknapp was seen by many QPR and non QPR fans alike to lead the club to safety. Failed.
Why anyone thinks Di Canio would have done better is a strange speculation indeed. He may have saved Sunderland for now, but his real baptism of fire will be next season. A bad start and he's sure to walk away and sharpish.
To be honest, I doubt anyone would have saved the club from the drop. It's a total shambles throughout. |  |
| There aint half been some clever bastards. |
| |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 10:24 - Apr 24 with 5251 views | MelakaRanger |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 09:08 - Apr 24 by Monahoop |
Despite the mess he inherited, Redknapp was seen by many QPR and non QPR fans alike to lead the club to safety. Failed.
Why anyone thinks Di Canio would have done better is a strange speculation indeed. He may have saved Sunderland for now, but his real baptism of fire will be next season. A bad start and he's sure to walk away and sharpish.
To be honest, I doubt anyone would have saved the club from the drop. It's a total shambles throughout. |
I agree with your last comment
The team that Hughes built and left us with was in such a state both mentally and ability wise, that I don't think anyone could have saved us.
No one could have saved QPR after Hughes' reign. No one. The difference at Sunderland was that they have a lot of players that WANT to play for the team and WANT the team to succeed. Its not full of under performing 'has-beens' or mercenaries.
But at QPR......................... |  | | |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 10:29 - Apr 24 with 5241 views | Metallica_Hoop |
I'd have Di Canio here like a shot.
I couldn't care less about his political views.
|  |
| Beer and Beef has made us what we are - The Prince Regent |
| |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 10:30 - Apr 24 with 5236 views | TheBlob |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 08:51 - Apr 24 by BrianMcCarthy |
Some things are not worth it. He's a fascist, and him walking through the door would be our lowest moment yet. |
If he'd saved us you would have licked his swastika.
 |  |
| |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 10:41 - Apr 24 with 5215 views | imustbemad |
Pretty sure no manager could have saved us with the starts we made coupled with the rabble we have for a team. The margins are small - wins against Villa/FulhamWigan, all possible at some point during those matches, might have made the difference. |  | | |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 10:43 - Apr 24 with 5212 views | CiderwithRsie |
He'd never have done it for reasons given by Stuabd and NeilSI. And it would have been a massive embarrassment for reasons given by Brian McCarthy.
Surprised we missed the chance to embarrass ourselves in this way really. In fact this is maybe the most feelgood thread on here right now. | | | |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 10:51 - Apr 24 with 5199 views | BrianMcCarthy |
LOL at Blob and Cider! | |
| |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 10:53 - Apr 24 with 5188 views | Jamie |
Wanted Di Canio or Solskjaer, knowing we were getting HR.
He wouldn't have kept us up, but he we'd be in far better condition to come back IMO. | | | |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 11:15 - Apr 24 with 5154 views | baz_qpr |
Definitely false, the only way we could have been saved was if the plug had been pulled on Hughes much earlier. It was clear as day we were in deep deep trouble by the time of West Ham at home, If HR had come in 4 or 5 games earlier I think we would have turned it around and been out of the bottom three by christmas and then would have had higher confidence and less pressure. The main problem all season until Remy was strikers and lack of them / goals). All to late by January though. |  | | |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 11:22 - Apr 24 with 5138 views | TacticalR |
I wouldn't have wanted him here. I haven't been impressed by his antics at other clubs.
However, I am trying to keep an open mind about whether there is more to him as a manager than his antics.
On a different note, according to Dwight Yorke's autobiography Sunderland's last brush with 'strong leadership' didn't end well:
'Paranoia rampaged through the club, players were at each other's throats and fighting one another; it was disintegrating before our very eyes....by now I was convinced that club management was not for Keano.' |  |
| |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 11:25 - Apr 24 with 5127 views | ozexile |
Only if he was signing Spider-Man to play in goal . | | | |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 11:40 - Apr 24 with 5094 views | TheBlob |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 10:24 - Apr 24 by MelakaRanger |
I agree with your last comment
The team that Hughes built and left us with was in such a state both mentally and ability wise, that I don't think anyone could have saved us.
No one could have saved QPR after Hughes' reign. No one. The difference at Sunderland was that they have a lot of players that WANT to play for the team and WANT the team to succeed. Its not full of under performing 'has-beens' or mercenaries.
But at QPR......................... |
Spot on.The Sunderland squad is littered with players that can respond to a touch of the cattle prod.You try that on some of our effete,temperamental ballet dancers and they go into their shell and sulk.
Blackmail,compromising photographs and /or kidnap of the family dog probably the only incentive. | |
| |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 12:10 - Apr 24 with 5061 views | Nov77 |
Would rather Luigi back than Paolo. |  |
| |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 12:14 - Apr 24 with 5054 views | switchingcode |
Don't think it would have any worse,but a def no from me rather have had kept NW in hindsight. | | | |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 12:15 - Apr 24 with 5052 views | NW5Hoop |
I'd rather be relegated with Paul Hart than saved with Di Canio. | | | |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 12:31 - Apr 24 with 5026 views | TheBlob |
| Di Canio would have saved QPR from relegation. on 12:15 - Apr 24 by NW5Hoop |
I'd rather be relegated with Paul Hart than saved with Di Canio. |
Yeah right. | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
