| Gomis 17:16 - Apr 4 with 7883 views | deanscfc |
Bony wouldn't have scored that first one. Great game from him today! |  | | |  |
| Gomis on 17:25 - Apr 4 with 4224 views | Groo |
Put this in the match thread but would like an answer
A tech question here, why was this not offside? when getting the ball Gomis was onside but when the ball was played forward he was miles offside.
When does not interfering start and stop? |  |
| Groo does what Groo does best |
| |
| Gomis on 17:27 - Apr 4 with 4209 views | JackFish |
The Hull defender played the ball, so it's technically a new phase of play. |  | | |
| Gomis on 17:34 - Apr 4 with 4156 views | Gundog |
Congrats gomis, a very good performance today kidda, take a bow son. | |
| |
| Gomis on 17:48 - Apr 4 with 4052 views | lovejuicejack |
Brilliant from gomis today well done, my words rammed down my throat. Chuffed for him and keep it up. |  | | |
| Gomis on 18:00 - Apr 4 with 3962 views | Huw57 |
Shows that Bafe feeds off confidence, he is a different animal with it. |  |
| |
| Gomis on 18:03 - Apr 4 with 3920 views | SkipTheJack |
IMHO Gomis was several yards offside for his first goal, but great finish! |  | | |
| Gomis on 18:04 - Apr 4 with 3913 views | PozuelosSideys |
| Gomis on 17:48 - Apr 4 by lovejuicejack |
Brilliant from gomis today well done, my words rammed down my throat. Chuffed for him and keep it up. |
Always great when one the players does that aint it! :) |  |
| "Michu, Britton and Williams could have won 3-0 on their own. They wouldn't have required a keeper." | | Poll: | Hattricks |
| |
| Gomis on 18:04 - Apr 4 with 3910 views | JJJack |
| Gomis on 17:48 - Apr 4 by lovejuicejack |
Brilliant from gomis today well done, my words rammed down my throat. Chuffed for him and keep it up. |
I'm sure many will be saying the same. IMO it's been obvious for a while that, given the way we play Gomis IS a good option for us. Literally the only problem was his failure to score. He's started 14 games on the trot since New Year's Day and scored 6 in those games. By anyone's standards that's pretty good. Bony scored 9 in 22 for us this season (though a few were as sub). |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Gomis on 18:11 - Apr 4 with 3852 views | WxmJax |
Hull players didn't complain as that is the offside rule. It's a crap rule that went our way today. The likes of Costa and van Nistelrooy are/were excellent at using it to their advantage but it's still a crap rule. |  |
| |
| Gomis on 18:13 - Apr 4 with 3830 views | icecoldjack |
Gomis= Enigma.
I think everyone is confused TBH! he has shown all colours of the Rainbow since being here and has probably had many posters changing their minds one way or another along the way.
He was superb today, i'm desperate for him to bang in the goals for the Swans, so well done to him. chuffed to bits for Bafa! |  | | |
| Gomis on 18:37 - Apr 4 with 3722 views | lovejuicejack |
| Gomis on 18:13 - Apr 4 by icecoldjack |
Gomis= Enigma.
I think everyone is confused TBH! he has shown all colours of the Rainbow since being here and has probably had many posters changing their minds one way or another along the way.
He was superb today, i'm desperate for him to bang in the goals for the Swans, so well done to him. chuffed to bits for Bafa! |
Excellent post iceman | | | |
| Gomis on 19:05 - Apr 4 with 3589 views | GrandPrix |
As people say it came off a hull player last so he was onside. Just like you can't be offside from a throw in (heard a few swans fans shout offside this season!)
Great rule I think, look at Danny Grahams goal v Chelsea in the semi final of the capital one cup.....offside but as they played the pass back he technically wasnt |  |
| Good times become good memories......bad times become lessons |
| |
| Gomis on 20:42 - Apr 4 with 3294 views | swans11 |
| Gomis on 19:05 - Apr 4 by GrandPrix |
As people say it came off a hull player last so he was onside. Just like you can't be offside from a throw in (heard a few swans fans shout offside this season!)
Great rule I think, look at Danny Grahams goal v Chelsea in the semi final of the capital one cup.....offside but as they played the pass back he technically wasnt |
Danny Graham goal nothing like gomis. We actually played ball forward so gomis was offside but he's been deemed onside as didn't play ball until defender has headed it. For me he's offside | | | |
| Gomis on 20:58 - Apr 4 with 3227 views | csf |
| Gomis on 20:42 - Apr 4 by swans11 |
Danny Graham goal nothing like gomis. We actually played ball forward so gomis was offside but he's been deemed onside as didn't play ball until defender has headed it. For me he's offside |
Yep, offside for me too, gained an advantage from being in an offside position |  | | |
| Gomis on 21:08 - Apr 4 with 3181 views | SkipTheJack |
The Gomis goal exposes an area of the offside rule that it generally poorly understood by fans, and perhaps even poorly defined in the laws. These days a player is not flagged offside unless he actually touches the ball, so what has to happen for him to become legally active again?
I know there are referees who post on here - I'd welcome the opinion of someone with more knowledge than the average fan.
At what stage does a player cease to be offside and can challenge for the ball again?
1. Is it when a defender touches the ball? Perhaps the type of touch from the defender also matters?
2. Or is it when the offside player gets back into an onside position?
3. Perhaps either the ball has to go dead or another attacker touch it after the player has returned to an onside position?
I'll be honest - I haven't got a clue! No guesses please - is anyone actually familiar with the rules? | | | |
| Gomis on 21:27 - Apr 4 with 3094 views | dgt73 |
| Gomis on 18:03 - Apr 4 by SkipTheJack |
IMHO Gomis was several yards offside for his first goal, but great finish! |
How can you be off-side when the ball comes off the defender...? I'll answer that for you....you can't......perfectly legal goal............  |  |
| |
| Gomis on 21:32 - Apr 4 with 3072 views | SkipTheJack |
| Gomis on 21:27 - Apr 4 by dgt73 |
How can you be off-side when the ball comes off the defender...? I'll answer that for you....you can't......perfectly legal goal............ |
I don't think it makes any difference that it came off a defender. Take our first goal for instance - if Ki had been offside when Jonjo shot then it wouldn't have made any difference that the ball came off McGregor last. He still would have been flagged. | | | |
| Gomis on 22:00 - Apr 4 with 2988 views | SwansNZ |
2 very well taken goals, and an excellent all round game from Gomis. |  |
| |
| Gomis on 22:07 - Apr 4 with 2961 views | dgt73 |
| Gomis on 21:32 - Apr 4 by SkipTheJack |
I don't think it makes any difference that it came off a defender. Take our first goal for instance - if Ki had been offside when Jonjo shot then it wouldn't have made any difference that the ball came off McGregor last. He still would have been flagged. |
You can't be off-side if the defender plays it, or has the last touch......and that's a FACT? | |
| |
| Gomis on 22:20 - Apr 4 with 2907 views | NeiltheTaylor |
| Gomis on 22:07 - Apr 4 by dgt73 |
You can't be off-side if the defender plays it, or has the last touch......and that's a FACT? |
Yes you can - for example, winger puts a ball in from deep position, striker is offside, skims off the top of defender's head, but end up at strikers feet. He is offside at the point the ball was played in. It would be coved under "gaining an advantage by being in an offside position"
Some people here need to look into the laws of football a bit more, obviously. Some applications vary, but generally they don't change.
You'll get the hang of it eventually. [Post edited 4 Apr 2015 22:23]
| |
| Joe_bradshaw -I thought the cryochamber was the new name for Cardiff's stadium.
|
| |
| Gomis on 22:30 - Apr 4 with 2862 views | GrandPrix |
| Gomis on 21:27 - Apr 4 by dgt73 |
How can you be off-side when the ball comes off the defender...? I'll answer that for you....you can't......perfectly legal goal............ |
And this is my point | |
| Good times become good memories......bad times become lessons |
| |
| Gomis on 22:41 - Apr 4 with 2807 views | dgt73 |
| Gomis on 22:20 - Apr 4 by NeiltheTaylor |
Yes you can - for example, winger puts a ball in from deep position, striker is offside, skims off the top of defender's head, but end up at strikers feet. He is offside at the point the ball was played in. It would be coved under "gaining an advantage by being in an offside position"
Some people here need to look into the laws of football a bit more, obviously. Some applications vary, but generally they don't change.
You'll get the hang of it eventually. [Post edited 4 Apr 2015 22:23]
|
And you are wrong with your example.............exhibit A......Danny Graham's goal v Chelsea, league cup semi final. | |
| |
| Gomis on 22:48 - Apr 4 with 2790 views | dgt73 |
| Gomis on 22:44 - Apr 4 by NeiltheTaylor |
You said that a player can't be offside if the ball touches an opposition player. You are wrong about that.
I haven't seen the Gomis goal again he was certainly in an offside position when the ball was played in. He was obviously deemed to not be gaining an advantage from that.
Like I say, you might want to understand these things a bit better as it helps to know what you're looking at. [Post edited 4 Apr 2015 22:44]
|
If you are in a offside position when the ball is played in.....and it scrims off a defender....and lands at your feet you are then deemed to be on side.........FACT..... [Post edited 4 Apr 2015 23:03]
| |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
