| Is McCarthy better than Green? 17:59 - Oct 19 with 9075 views | QPRMUSO |
I thought he looked very composed, didn't show any signs of flapping that Green always does once in a game, who is the understudy, it should be green in my view? |  | | |  |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 18:01 - Oct 19 with 5913 views | Hunterhoop |
Yes. He comes for crosses. |  | | |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 18:18 - Oct 19 with 5862 views | PunteR |
His goal kicks are good. You could see he was picking out BZ who i thought was excellent.
Made 2 good saves.
Hard to say if he's better then Green as Green i think is consistent. I would like McCarthy to get a run of games now. Young,ambitious and an up and coming player is what QPR need at the moment. |  |
| Occasional providers of half decent House music. |
| |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 19:29 - Oct 19 with 5737 views | Gloucs_R |
McCarthy was quality today, his save that fell to Balloteli was superb. Absolutley massive as well. Was Green injured or completely dropped? |  |
| |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 19:34 - Oct 19 with 5719 views | kysersosaqpr |
Yes | |
| The greatest trick the devil ever pulled was convincing the world he didn't exist. |
| |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 19:34 - Oct 19 with 5718 views | BklynRanger |
No idea of the answer to that question but he doesn't appear to be rubbish.
This may only make sense to me, but his goal keeping seems to have more of an athletic snap to it than Green's. |  | | |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 19:35 - Oct 19 with 5710 views | PhilmyRs |
Like him. Would give him a run in the side. Haven't seen it back but thought maybe he should have been off his line quicker for the 3rd. Think he could have made it before sterling. | | | |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 19:38 - Oct 19 with 5691 views | collegeranger |
Green has tonsillitis. Thought his display was very good neither him for Rob Green could have done anything really for the 3 goals! Good to have 2 top class keepers and no controversy!! |  | | |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 19:42 - Oct 19 with 5668 views | Jigsore |
I would give him a run in the team too. We've got 2 good keepers here but McCarthy is only going to get better, maybe even a future England keeper if we don't ruin him completely.
i think Green is a good dressing room presence though so it's good if he's still in and around the first team [Post edited 19 Oct 2014 19:42]
|  |
| “The thing about football - the important thing about football - is that it is not just about football.†|
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 19:46 - Oct 19 with 5649 views | quickpassrotter |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 19:29 - Oct 19 by Gloucs_R |
McCarthy was quality today, his save that fell to Balloteli was superb. Absolutley massive as well. Was Green injured or completely dropped? |
Green has tonsillitis. |  | | |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 19:46 - Oct 19 with 5646 views | johncharles |
Has Harry sold Green to Leicester ? |  |
| Strong and stable my arse. |
| |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 23:03 - Oct 19 with 5488 views | INFIRMARY |
based on today , miles better , looks in charge of the goal area |  |
| |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 23:17 - Oct 19 with 5451 views | JonDoeman |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 23:03 - Oct 19 by INFIRMARY |
based on today , miles better , looks in charge of the goal area |
agree. |  |
| |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 23:24 - Oct 19 with 5423 views | loftboy |
I'm a firm believer that if a player starts even if it's only because of illness but plays well he should remain in the side until he no longer deserves to, will be interesting to see what happens once Green is fit again. |  |
| |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 23:27 - Oct 19 with 5414 views | JonDoeman |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 23:24 - Oct 19 by loftboy |
I'm a firm believer that if a player starts even if it's only because of illness but plays well he should remain in the side until he no longer deserves to, will be interesting to see what happens once Green is fit again. |
Yeah Loftboy, Rio & Green should stay dropped.!! | |
| |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 23:45 - Oct 19 with 5403 views | davman |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 23:24 - Oct 19 by loftboy |
I'm a firm believer that if a player starts even if it's only because of illness but plays well he should remain in the side until he no longer deserves to, will be interesting to see what happens once Green is fit again. |
This will be a real test of Harry and his favourites. McCarthy is just as good, if not better than Green and is the future. Let Green suffer on the bench and watch him fight for his place.
...or Harry will revert to type and put his 'boy' in... |  |
| |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 00:07 - Oct 20 with 5372 views | Monkey_Roots |
I thought he looked good, although I think he could have come out for their third - it's one of them though, come out and miss it and you'll always have the calamity tag.
I'm a bit surprised at some of the comments on here regarding Green though, I know he has a howler every so often, but he has been a really good keeper for us. I think I would rather see a bit more of McCarthy before dismembering green and dumping his body back down into the championship. Plus he got a proper raw deal off Hughes and stuck with us... Quid pro quo or some sh1t. |  | | |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 01:05 - Oct 20 with 5333 views | Trom |
Being a Berkshire boy in my youth (Crowthorne originally) I have a few Reading mates. They really rate him. I like Green and he's a great shot stopper but mistakes are his downfall. |  | | |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 08:48 - Oct 20 with 5206 views | timcocking |
Yes? |  | | |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 08:57 - Oct 20 with 5194 views | ElHoop |
At the end of the day he let in three goals so it's difficult to say that he's an improvement, but the issue for me was his distribution and that looked OK yesterday. However Liverpool didn't press us at the back and he was mostly hoofing it up the park anyway. If we didn't have two big men up front then his distribution would come under more pressure, but overall he looked up to the job on this performance. |  | | |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 09:03 - Oct 20 with 5180 views | Gloucs_R |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 08:57 - Oct 20 by ElHoop |
At the end of the day he let in three goals so it's difficult to say that he's an improvement, but the issue for me was his distribution and that looked OK yesterday. However Liverpool didn't press us at the back and he was mostly hoofing it up the park anyway. If we didn't have two big men up front then his distribution would come under more pressure, but overall he looked up to the job on this performance. |
Two goals were going harmlessly across the goal and the other was deflected. | |
| |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 09:17 - Oct 20 with 5152 views | ElHoop |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 09:03 - Oct 20 by Gloucs_R |
Two goals were going harmlessly across the goal and the other was deflected. |
I don't know either way really. The jury's out for me. I played CB at a low level and you needed help from the keeper in terms of calling time (not in the Dunne pub landlord sense) or man on or whatever. Only the defenders themselves can know whether they received maximum assistance. | | | |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 15:26 - Oct 23 with 4983 views | kingsburyR |
As the game closes in I really hope we stick with McCarthy for the Villa game.
For no other reason then that he looks more like a keeper than Green!
He's a big lad and more imposing! |  |
| Dont know why we bother. .... but we do! |
| |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 15:30 - Oct 23 with 4975 views | Northernr |
Yes. |  | | |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 15:34 - Oct 23 with 4966 views | toboboly |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 09:17 - Oct 20 by ElHoop |
I don't know either way really. The jury's out for me. I played CB at a low level and you needed help from the keeper in terms of calling time (not in the Dunne pub landlord sense) or man on or whatever. Only the defenders themselves can know whether they received maximum assistance. |
If you think that any keeper would have been at fault for the three goals we conceded then I am glad I never played in your defence. |  |
| Sexy Asian dwarves wanted. |
| |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 15:59 - Oct 23 with 4927 views | ElHoop |
| Is McCarthy better than Green? on 15:34 - Oct 23 by toboboly |
If you think that any keeper would have been at fault for the three goals we conceded then I am glad I never played in your defence. |
Crumbs, Toboboly successfully splits a hair with a computer keyboard and two fingers. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
