Forum | Chair by Logman |

Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread

Chair 19:02 - Dec 7 with 8483 views

Going to have to work hard to get back in the side.

Not going to get in ahead of Saito or Smyth for work-rate, and potentially productivity. By the time he is back might not get in ahead of Kolli for final product.

Nice dilemma to have !

[Post edited 7 Dec 19:08]

Chair on 17:12 - Dec 10 with 1479 views

daveB

Chair on 16:12 - Dec 10 by TK1

Chair's right footed. He's played there before and he's 10x the player Smyth is. Smyth has one assist and zero goals playing wide in a front three from eleven games. I reckon Chair can manage that.

There's a role for Smyth. But come on. Anyway, I'd play Chair in the middle instead of Madsen, working and swapping with Saito as he did best with Willock. Not sure Smyth will get away with overhitting passes to Chair and blaming him quite so often.

has he played right wing before?
I agree he's a better player than Smyth but he doesn't strike me as someone who would go on the outside on his stronger foot, i wouldn't be against trying it but not sure it will work

Chair on 17:19 - Dec 10 with 1433 views

kensalriser

Smyth's a winger, Chair isn't. Chair could probably play Smyth's position better than Smyth could play Chair's, but bombing down the wing and sending in crosses would hardly be the best use of his abilities.

Poll:

QPR to finish 7th or Brentford to drop out of the top 6?

Chair on 17:47 - Dec 10 with 1360 views

Lanhoop

Unless it's critical we don't seem to put anyone back in the team after an injury. Couple of matches on the bench with increasing minutes on the pitch each time appears to be the approach and I'd expect that to apply to Chair.

Chair on 18:18 - Dec 10 with 1281 views

Hoopstar

The club have an option on Chair's contract so he is effectively under contract to Summer 2026 tbf.

Chair on 19:09 - Dec 10 with 1162 views

Benny_the_Ball

Chair on 18:18 - Dec 10 by Hoopstar
The club have an option on Chair's contract so he is effectively under contract to Summer 2026 tbf.

That's somewhat comforting. In that case if Paal doesn't renew we could see him leave in January, with Saito/Ashby/A.N.Other covering until the end of the season. Then it's time to sweat on Ilias' future.

Chair on 19:25 - Dec 10 with 1086 views

davman

Chair on 10:46 - Dec 8 by nix

I don't think we can completely compare the two based on one admittedly very good performance yesterday. Although Kolli did very well only two teams have let in more goals this season than Norwich as well as Norwich being much worse away from home. I thought their defence was poor, allowing us more space and not doubling up on our players as much as other teams do, suggesting their attackers don't help out enough at the back. Normally Celar's playing against two CBs and gets nowhere near the space Kolli had yesterday.

I'd like to see him play against better defences before being entirely sure of his hold up play.

The space their defenders gave him for the first goal was shocking. He had a clear run to that header as no-one squeezed him in and the second one was also a howler following some good Madsen pressure.

Not taking anything away from the lad at all, but nix is right here.

Hopefully Oxford are as bad tomorrow and / or Kolli steps up even more...

	Can we go out yet?
Poll:	What would you take for Willock if a bid comes this month?

Chair on 13:08 - Dec 11 with 875 views

stainrods_elbow

Chair on 17:11 - Dec 10 by Benny_the_Ball

Let's not get carried away by a couple of wins. With all things being equal a fully fit and firing Ilias Chair gets into this team. The conundrum for the manager is where to play him, the system to deploy, and who drops out.

On a side note, both Paal and Chair's contracts expire in the summer of 2025. In the absence of new deals, one would think that the club would look to sell at least one of them in January. Chair would fetch the better money and we have a ready made replacement in Dembele. Conversely, Saito has equipped himself well at LB so could cover there should Paal depart. Decisions, decisions...

Dembele is hardly a 'ready-made' placement for Chair or anyone - he's a promising kid who's shown brief flashes of talent before getting what's apparently a bad/worrying injury. If Chair doesn't sign a new contract (he still may well do) anytime soon, and we end up selling in January (assuming we get a credible buyer payiong a sensible fee), we will need to reinvest at least some of that money on a playmaker.

Poll:

What points will we get from our 'Festive 3' (Swansea A, Norwich A, Watford H)?

Chair on 13:26 - Dec 11 with 796 views

TheChef

Chair on 13:08 - Dec 11 by stainrods_elbow

Appreciate he's young (well, 21) but he did play a full season for Blackpool last season so I wouldn't say he's quite as inexperienced as you think.

Poll:

How old is everyone on here?

Chair on 16:17 - Dec 11 with 633 views

Benny_the_Ball

Chair on 13:08 - Dec 11 by stainrods_elbow

Eze, Chair, BOS, etc. were all promising kids when they joined QPR. None of them were the finished article. It's what we do now. Dembele is at a similar, if not arguably better level than Chair was when Ilias was 21. In our world, that's a ready-made replacement. It's now down to the coaching team to develop him into the real deal.

Moreover, we have quite a few "playmakers" at the club. Chair, Dembele, Saito, Anderson, Madsen. If we do sell Chair, I'd shake hands with Lucas and use some of the revenue to secure Koki on a permanent basis. The rest would be invested elsewhere in the team where there is more pressing need.

Chair on 16:36 - Dec 11 with 572 views

Logman

I agree re Dembele. He has the attributes to replace Chair.

It's what we do, train them up and sell them on.

I don't know if anyone read the latest Development Squad report but it sounds like there is a 15 year old coming through who is alreay cutting the mustard with the 18 year olds.

Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread