| Jake Bidwell 14:29 - Apr 16 with 7994 views | Red_Ranger |
Watching him yesterday said it all. - And they got him on a free from Swansea. |  | | |  |
| Jake Bidwell on 22:16 - Apr 16 with 2241 views | stevenagehoop |
Came from Brentford and in my opinion did not have the same success with us. No pace, often wrong side of his man and was not good enough at defending. Wasn’t upset when he moved on the fact that we are struggling now doesn’t make his ability any better. |  |
| I never lie but I don't always tell the truth |
| |
| Jake Bidwell on 18:41 - Apr 17 with 1889 views | PinnerPaul |
| Jake Bidwell on 17:47 - Apr 16 by connell10 |
He was crap, come on mate stop rewriting history ! |
Where's the re writing in that 1st paragraph , he's played all his football since he left above us and DID keep Manning out of the team at Swansea for over a year. | | | |
| Jake Bidwell on 18:42 - Apr 17 with 1875 views | PinnerPaul |
| Jake Bidwell on 18:12 - Apr 16 by Antti_Heinola |
Nope he was a decent mid table left sided defender. His entire career is proof of that. |
Yep! | | | |
| Jake Bidwell on 19:01 - Apr 17 with 1839 views | francisbowles |
| Jake Bidwell on 18:12 - Apr 16 by Antti_Heinola |
Nope he was a decent mid table left sided defender. His entire career is proof of that. |
Sorry Antti hit down vote, meant to hit up vote. | | | |
| Jake Bidwell on 19:11 - Apr 17 with 1800 views | ParkRoyalR |
| Jake Bidwell on 18:41 - Apr 17 by PinnerPaul |
Where's the re writing in that 1st paragraph , he's played all his football since he left above us and DID keep Manning out of the team at Swansea for over a year. |
Yet.....Swansea ended up giving Bidwell away and turning Manning into one of the top-performers in the Championship, scoring goals and leading with assists
Yes.....the same Manning derided by a few on here, was actually so good Swansea were prepared to let Bidwell go on a free
Really who would have guessed heh, and all the while the mugs down the Bush wasted £1m up front £ 2m+ in wages on old cart-horse Bidders, when they could have picked up a better full-back from non-league for a tenth of that cost. | | | |
| Jake Bidwell on 13:30 - Apr 18 with 1612 views | gazza1 |
| Jake Bidwell on 19:11 - Apr 17 by ParkRoyalR |
Yet.....Swansea ended up giving Bidwell away and turning Manning into one of the top-performers in the Championship, scoring goals and leading with assists
Yes.....the same Manning derided by a few on here, was actually so good Swansea were prepared to let Bidwell go on a free
Really who would have guessed heh, and all the while the mugs down the Bush wasted £1m up front £ 2m+ in wages on old cart-horse Bidders, when they could have picked up a better full-back from non-league for a tenth of that cost. |
So Bidwell is rubbish & Dykes is the 'best thing since sliced bread' eh......says it all!!!! | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Jake Bidwell on 13:37 - Apr 18 with 1576 views | ParkRoyalR |
| Jake Bidwell on 13:30 - Apr 18 by gazza1 |
So Bidwell is rubbish & Dykes is the 'best thing since sliced bread' eh......says it all!!!! |
I was'nt a fan of Bidwell in part due to his rumoured wages offered to entice him from Brentford (apparently we offered £15k p/w, double what Brentford would pay him) but more due to his lackadaisical stroll back past the paddock when getting back into position after crossing the halfway line.
A very very average player, who played for himself and not the team, hence always the 5 yard pass inside to his Centre Half when he was in a better position to move the ball himself.
Brentford fans sussed him out, most Managers who have free-transferred him have likewise, if you rate him, fair enough. | | | |
| Jake Bidwell on 13:46 - Apr 18 with 1561 views | gazza1 |
| Jake Bidwell on 13:37 - Apr 18 by ParkRoyalR |
I was'nt a fan of Bidwell in part due to his rumoured wages offered to entice him from Brentford (apparently we offered £15k p/w, double what Brentford would pay him) but more due to his lackadaisical stroll back past the paddock when getting back into position after crossing the halfway line.
A very very average player, who played for himself and not the team, hence always the 5 yard pass inside to his Centre Half when he was in a better position to move the ball himself.
Brentford fans sussed him out, most Managers who have free-transferred him have likewise, if you rate him, fair enough. |
How do you know the financial side of his contract, etc, etc???? Who cares anyway, not our issue. It is how he plays.
I look at what I saw and what I saw was a fair enough 'run of the mill' left sided player and I think that the number of professional games confirm what I believe. Team player as well, blame him for being not close enough to the CB's, why not blame the CBs for being too close together??
To call him 'shite' is poor & wrong - he wasn't, he was limited like most, if not all, of our players.
As for Brentford fans.....well, look at swithingcode post on P1. He states 'solid'.
I expect better from you PRR!!! [Post edited 18 Apr 2023 13:50]
| | | |
| Jake Bidwell on 14:16 - Apr 18 with 1504 views | robith |
Bidwell was an adequate championship left back for us. Probably indicative of where we are as a club that a 6/10 player is being argued over like he was an 8 or a 1.
I did always enjoy how Joel Lynch used to try and blame everything on Bidwell. I recall once him passing it back straight to an unmarked striker, and after the goal Lynch's first instinct was to blame Bidwell, before settling on the "stare at the sky" response |  | | |
| Jake Bidwell on 14:58 - Apr 18 with 1443 views | ParkRoyalR |
| Jake Bidwell on 13:46 - Apr 18 by gazza1 |
How do you know the financial side of his contract, etc, etc???? Who cares anyway, not our issue. It is how he plays.
I look at what I saw and what I saw was a fair enough 'run of the mill' left sided player and I think that the number of professional games confirm what I believe. Team player as well, blame him for being not close enough to the CB's, why not blame the CBs for being too close together??
To call him 'shite' is poor & wrong - he wasn't, he was limited like most, if not all, of our players.
As for Brentford fans.....well, look at swithingcode post on P1. He states 'solid'.
I expect better from you PRR!!! [Post edited 18 Apr 2023 13:50]
|
A 'solid' player in League 1 for Brentford maybe, not sure why Switchingcode said he copped abuse from Brentfords fans if he was so 'solid'
To call him 'shite' may or may not be poor or wrong, but that's irrelevant because I did'nt call him 'shite', read my post again.
I do care about the financial side as when you see how much money in fees + wages we have wasted on the likes of Bidwell (£3m), Washington (£4.5m), Austin last year, Johansen this year, you quickly realise why we are in such a mess and losing £20m odd pa. | | | |
| Jake Bidwell on 15:13 - Apr 18 with 1429 views | gazza1 |
| Jake Bidwell on 14:58 - Apr 18 by ParkRoyalR |
A 'solid' player in League 1 for Brentford maybe, not sure why Switchingcode said he copped abuse from Brentfords fans if he was so 'solid'
To call him 'shite' may or may not be poor or wrong, but that's irrelevant because I did'nt call him 'shite', read my post again.
I do care about the financial side as when you see how much money in fees + wages we have wasted on the likes of Bidwell (£3m), Washington (£4.5m), Austin last year, Johansen this year, you quickly realise why we are in such a mess and losing £20m odd pa. |
Poor response PRR......
Switchingcode said he was a solid player....end off. He watched him enough playing for Brentford and that is his opinion - your post reflects the opposite. Dont care about abuse from Bees fans.
To call him 'Shite' is wrong & poor and you should recognise that. Not saying that you did call him 'shite'.
You may care about the financial side but that isn't the issue......you do not know what financial terms he moved from Brentford to QPR - it is pure speculation on your behalf. | | | |
| Jake Bidwell on 15:24 - Apr 18 with 1419 views | ParkRoyalR |
| Jake Bidwell on 15:13 - Apr 18 by gazza1 |
Poor response PRR......
Switchingcode said he was a solid player....end off. He watched him enough playing for Brentford and that is his opinion - your post reflects the opposite. Dont care about abuse from Bees fans.
To call him 'Shite' is wrong & poor and you should recognise that. Not saying that you did call him 'shite'.
You may care about the financial side but that isn't the issue......you do not know what financial terms he moved from Brentford to QPR - it is pure speculation on your behalf. |
Pure speculation would be he left Brentford because he wanted to move to closer to the Bush as The Conny was his favourite craft beer pub,
In all probability, it was a move motivated by money and the likelihood he would be playing understudy to a far superior player sourced from the lower league / non-league (Walsall) in Rico Henry
And was embarrassing himself in training sessions daily against Jota, remember him, could'nt get in Birmingham's team and absolutely tore Bidwell a new one at Griffin Park, was'nt so solid that day. | | | |
| Jake Bidwell on 15:29 - Apr 18 with 1403 views | gazza1 |
| Jake Bidwell on 15:24 - Apr 18 by ParkRoyalR |
Pure speculation would be he left Brentford because he wanted to move to closer to the Bush as The Conny was his favourite craft beer pub,
In all probability, it was a move motivated by money and the likelihood he would be playing understudy to a far superior player sourced from the lower league / non-league (Walsall) in Rico Henry
And was embarrassing himself in training sessions daily against Jota, remember him, could'nt get in Birmingham's team and absolutely tore Bidwell a new one at Griffin Park, was'nt so solid that day. |
Another 'pxss poor' response PRR - I really do expect better.
I am not going to pull your/that post to pieces, you should have learnt from the previous one.
I am done with this Bidwell thread......no more from me, have fun!! | | | |
| Jake Bidwell on 15:42 - Apr 18 with 1381 views | EastR |
simple one this
would Bidwell get in our team and be first choice? would he improve us?
yes to both from me | |
| |
| Jake Bidwell on 16:39 - Apr 18 with 1331 views | ParkRoyalR |
| Jake Bidwell on 15:42 - Apr 18 by EastR |
simple one this
would Bidwell get in our team and be first choice? would he improve us?
yes to both from me |
For me, no chance,
Paal is a far superior player. | | | |
| Jake Bidwell on 17:04 - Apr 19 with 1112 views | stevenagehoop |
| Jake Bidwell on 15:42 - Apr 18 by EastR |
simple one this
would Bidwell get in our team and be first choice? would he improve us?
yes to both from me |
so would Padula have and would much rather have him - at the relevant time we could and should have had someone better than Bidwell | |
| I never lie but I don't always tell the truth |
| |
| Jake Bidwell on 18:35 - Apr 19 with 1033 views | PinnerPaul |
| Jake Bidwell on 17:04 - Apr 19 by stevenagehoop |
so would Padula have and would much rather have him - at the relevant time we could and should have had someone better than Bidwell |
Padula wouldn't now but Bidwell would is the rather obvious response to that argument. | | | |
| Jake Bidwell on 19:12 - Apr 19 with 1017 views | stevenagehoop |
| Jake Bidwell on 18:35 - Apr 19 by PinnerPaul |
Padula wouldn't now but Bidwell would is the rather obvious response to that argument. |
You’re correct in saying that Bidwell might just have the edge over an aged Padula😀 but I still need convincing that he is better than Paal - didn’t rate him in a rangers shirt and still don’t. | |
| I never lie but I don't always tell the truth |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
