Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? 16:41 - Aug 23 with 8584 viewsArgyBargy1982

Net £3m - £4m spent and have we ended up with a better player?
0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 16:45 - Aug 23 with 6649 viewsrsonist

Let go.
0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 16:50 - Aug 23 with 6614 viewspomanjou

PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 16:45 - Aug 23 by rsonist

Let go.


We don't know how much was spent and we haven't seen the guy in the Hoops.
Not that Phillips will have to do a lot to convince me that he is better than Mackie........

Currently residing in Pinner, Centre of the Universe.
Poll: we have a timetable for Brexit, should there be a referendum for the English

0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 16:51 - Aug 23 with 6597 viewsTonto

yes we have.

but thanks for asking

Why stop now, just when I'm hating it
Poll: How was the transfer window for you?

0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 16:53 - Aug 23 with 6587 viewsHOOPNO7

Yes he is.
0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 16:56 - Aug 23 with 6547 viewsPhildo

Love Mackie but this fella has the potential to be a much better player
0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 17:30 - Aug 23 with 6393 viewshoopstilidie

Phillips has yet to reach his full potential, Mackie already has.

Ringo Starr ate my hamper.
Poll: Yes or no?

0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 17:32 - Aug 23 with 6379 viewsGloucs_R

Yes, he is. Mackie is a trier but not a winger and not a forward. Phillips is supposed to be mustard!

Poll: Are we staying up?

0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 17:34 - Aug 23 with 6369 viewsbaz_qpr

Having not seen much of him its hard to answer but we've bought a 22 year old and sold a 27 year old so that seems like sensible business
0
Login to get fewer ads

PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 17:45 - Aug 23 with 6306 viewsFearless

The answers no - IMHO

Footballs about what you've done - more than about what you might do.

Mackie was a catalyst (eg away at Derby) and was a crucial part (injury aside) of the team that actually won something!
And he scored memorable goals such as Liverpool at home.

Phillips MIGHT go on to achieve similar, and I hope he does.

However, currently the jury's out as to whether he's Richard Ord or Martin Rowlands (ie signed whilst injured)

Just my opinion
0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 17:49 - Aug 23 with 6286 viewsbosh67

He's a different player to Mackie. He's definitely the player you get when you can't get Townsend. Him, Townsend and Austin would have a field day. Pleased we've got Phillips, I've seen him play a few times and he's similar in style to Townsend, albeit right footed, and he is very very quick at this level. Plus he's over 6 foot and apparently good in the air too.

Never knowingly right.
Poll: How long before new signings become quivering wrecks of the players they were?

0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 17:52 - Aug 23 with 6269 viewskingo

PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 17:49 - Aug 23 by bosh67

He's a different player to Mackie. He's definitely the player you get when you can't get Townsend. Him, Townsend and Austin would have a field day. Pleased we've got Phillips, I've seen him play a few times and he's similar in style to Townsend, albeit right footed, and he is very very quick at this level. Plus he's over 6 foot and apparently good in the air too.


Better is him, Austin and Hoilett surely.

RIP: Sniffer, Doug and Pat

0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 17:58 - Aug 23 with 6238 views100percent

if he can trap a ball and then run with it at his feet, I'd say yes, he's a better player.
0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 17:58 - Aug 23 with 6237 viewsbosh67

PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 17:52 - Aug 23 by kingo

Better is him, Austin and Hoilett surely.


Agreed but who's this Surely character?

Never knowingly right.
Poll: How long before new signings become quivering wrecks of the players they were?

0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 18:05 - Aug 23 with 6212 viewsInglesio

PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 17:58 - Aug 23 by 100percent

if he can trap a ball and then run with it at his feet, I'd say yes, he's a better player.


0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 21:10 - Aug 23 with 5948 viewsTW_R

PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 17:45 - Aug 23 by Fearless

The answers no - IMHO

Footballs about what you've done - more than about what you might do.

Mackie was a catalyst (eg away at Derby) and was a crucial part (injury aside) of the team that actually won something!
And he scored memorable goals such as Liverpool at home.

Phillips MIGHT go on to achieve similar, and I hope he does.

However, currently the jury's out as to whether he's Richard Ord or Martin Rowlands (ie signed whilst injured)

Just my opinion


"Footballs about what you've done - more than about what you might do."

So we should've signed Pele and Maradonna?
0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 21:29 - Aug 23 with 5895 viewsFearless

PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 21:10 - Aug 23 by TW_R

"Footballs about what you've done - more than about what you might do."

So we should've signed Pele and Maradonna?


Apologies for not making myself clear.

My point was that Mackie has achieved for QPR - whether individuals rate him as a player or not.
Phillips hasn't - YET

Therefore - is Phillips better than Mackie (for QPR) = no (for now)
In a years time, the answer could be yes.

I don't understand your reference to Pele and Maradona
0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 21:45 - Aug 23 with 5851 viewsMedwayR

PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 21:29 - Aug 23 by Fearless

Apologies for not making myself clear.

My point was that Mackie has achieved for QPR - whether individuals rate him as a player or not.
Phillips hasn't - YET

Therefore - is Phillips better than Mackie (for QPR) = no (for now)
In a years time, the answer could be yes.

I don't understand your reference to Pele and Maradona


I think you're looking at it the wrong way, it's not about what Mackie has done for us in the past, it's what he would've done for us in the future. For my money Phillips will give us more than Mackie would have.

Poll: Who’s better?

0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 21:53 - Aug 23 with 5815 viewsFearless

PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 21:45 - Aug 23 by MedwayR

I think you're looking at it the wrong way, it's not about what Mackie has done for us in the past, it's what he would've done for us in the future. For my money Phillips will give us more than Mackie would have.


Fair enough
0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 21:57 - Aug 23 with 5799 viewsTW_R

PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 21:29 - Aug 23 by Fearless

Apologies for not making myself clear.

My point was that Mackie has achieved for QPR - whether individuals rate him as a player or not.
Phillips hasn't - YET

Therefore - is Phillips better than Mackie (for QPR) = no (for now)
In a years time, the answer could be yes.

I don't understand your reference to Pele and Maradona


Well I was just being a bit silly really, but the point was really that Pele and Maradona both achieved a lot more than Mackie, but it doesn't mean they would be better than him now. Because a player hasn't played for QPR yet doesn't mean he can't be better than a player who has.
0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 22:01 - Aug 23 with 5789 viewsdolcelatte

Phillips is Windows 7 whereas Mackie is Windows 95 and no longer supported.

Poll: Are you sick of people asking if you are sick of polls?

0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 22:02 - Aug 23 with 5784 viewsBrazilNutR

I hope so....

but then i was excited when we signed SWP and Hoilet.... and they came with good reputations and experience and have done nothing so far really. Mackie came and was a fairly underwhelming signing...but did very well and suprised me.
I think Remy is the only signing I can really remember that was a big name and big money signing that actually looked his worth once he put on the hoops...
0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 22:06 - Aug 23 with 5775 viewsEsgaroth

PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 22:01 - Aug 23 by dolcelatte

Phillips is Windows 7 whereas Mackie is Windows 95 and no longer supported.



Been here since 1984. Now THAT is what you call punishment

0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 22:49 - Aug 23 with 5672 viewsCamberleyR

If he's half as good as the last winger we signed from Blackpool, he'll be some player.

Poll: Which is the worst QPR team?

0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 23:56 - Aug 23 with 5555 viewsCanadaRanger

PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 22:01 - Aug 23 by dolcelatte

Phillips is Windows 7 whereas Mackie is Windows 95 and no longer supported.


No intention to dis Phillips (whom I haven't seen yet), but....

I'd still take old but reliable Windows 95 over some of the other operators we hired recently.

Those overpaid, underachieving players that were supposed to give us a solid foundation in the Premiership were Windows CE, Windows Me and Windows NT mixed into one... That would be Windows CEMeNT...
0
PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 00:03 - Aug 24 with 5538 viewsWestbourneR

PHILLIPS BETTER THAN MACKIE? on 17:58 - Aug 23 by 100percent

if he can trap a ball and then run with it at his feet, I'd say yes, he's a better player.


Said in one. Well done that man

Poll: Should JFH get the sack?

0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2024