| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" 23:43 - Feb 1 with 4384 views | JackFish |
...I'm still not seeing the part where he won the ball? |  | | |  |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 23:44 - Feb 1 with 3372 views | Darran |
Nor me. |  |
| |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 23:47 - Feb 1 with 3350 views | inspector |
theres one angle where you just see him scrape the ball with his studs. |  | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 23:49 - Feb 1 with 3328 views | JackFish |
Was that before or after he'd cleared out Bony?
Having seen the red card again I've got no sympathy for Carrol, he's taken a big swing with his elbow there. | | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 00:05 - Feb 2 with 3247 views | WarwickHunt |
Came in from the side and got a touch. Not a penalty. |  | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 00:15 - Feb 2 with 3196 views | LeonisGod |
You can see it on HD  |  | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 00:18 - Feb 2 with 3188 views | jack_lord |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 00:05 - Feb 2 by WarwickHunt |
Came in from the side and got a touch. Not a penalty. |
I was wondering about this, it was the thinnest possible of touches and was nailed on penalty otherwise. |  |
| |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 00:48 - Feb 2 with 3129 views | Catullus |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 00:15 - Feb 2 by LeonisGod |
You can see it on HD |
Yep, took two replays though!!
And Carroll's card was for intent I think. Maybe would have been yellow if Chico hadn't given such a determined (if disgraceful) performance!!
If only we'd put as much effort in as Tomkins st al. |  |
| |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 08:46 - Feb 2 with 2960 views | caerleon_jack |
Touching the ball means nothing - if you have to foul the guy to get to the ball, it's a foul. Collins put in a similar tackle 5 minutes later, but outside the box and a freekick was given.
Also no sympathy for Carroll. He meant to hit Chico, he was just unlucky that a) Chico was on his knees at the time, and b) it was Chico |  |
| Insert something witty here |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 08:55 - Feb 2 with 2932 views | latchford |
Penalty and red at that stage and we'd have had three points I have no doubt. | | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 09:02 - Feb 2 with 2907 views | johnlangy |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 23:47 - Feb 1 by inspector |
theres one angle where you just see him scrape the ball with his studs. |
Exactly. He got the ball first, unfortunately. | | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 09:04 - Feb 2 with 2892 views | shandyjack |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 08:46 - Feb 2 by caerleon_jack |
Touching the ball means nothing - if you have to foul the guy to get to the ball, it's a foul. Collins put in a similar tackle 5 minutes later, but outside the box and a freekick was given.
Also no sympathy for Carroll. He meant to hit Chico, he was just unlucky that a) Chico was on his knees at the time, and b) it was Chico |
correct on all 3 points |  |
| |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 09:06 - Feb 2 with 2884 views | AnotherJohn |
It was a difficult one to call and not having had the chance to see many replays I'm still not sure. My first impression though that the defender misses the ball completely with his first lunge but then scrapes his stud on the ball as it bounces back up off the ground. It was also my impression that Tomkins made contact with Bony in between those events, and if he did then it was a penalty kick. I don't blame the ref as I think it could have gone either way, but at the same time we are not getting our fair share of these 50/50 calls. | | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 09:08 - Feb 2 with 2878 views | SkaFace |
BT mentioned before kick off that Webb hasn't given a penalty yet. I saw it in real time a thought it was a penalty, even in the replay it took a couple of times to see the slightest of touches to change the direction of the ball but the full force on Bony's knee first. Must be a foul if you take the player before or after you supposedly get the ball.
There wasn't a big appeal from our players though, unlike the sending off. | | | |
| (No subject) on 09:15 - Feb 2 with 2848 views | AnotherJohn |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 09:08 - Feb 2 by SkaFace |
BT mentioned before kick off that Webb hasn't given a penalty yet. I saw it in real time a thought it was a penalty, even in the replay it took a couple of times to see the slightest of touches to change the direction of the ball but the full force on Bony's knee first. Must be a foul if you take the player before or after you supposedly get the ball.
There wasn't a big appeal from our players though, unlike the sending off. |
I think if he makes contact with the player after touching the ball it is not a pen, while the reverse is a penalty. [Post edited 2 Feb 2014 9:15]
| | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 09:17 - Feb 2 with 2822 views | Phil_S |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 09:08 - Feb 2 by SkaFace |
BT mentioned before kick off that Webb hasn't given a penalty yet. I saw it in real time a thought it was a penalty, even in the replay it took a couple of times to see the slightest of touches to change the direction of the ball but the full force on Bony's knee first. Must be a foul if you take the player before or after you supposedly get the ball.
There wasn't a big appeal from our players though, unlike the sending off. |
Which probably suggests they thought it wasn't penalty? |  | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 11:17 - Feb 2 with 2644 views | yescomeon |
Though it was a stone waller. The only reason I can imagine the ref didn't give it is he saw the change of direction of the ball and assumed that Tomkins made contact with the ball. Where is the advantage to the attacker? |  |
| |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 11:23 - Feb 2 with 2631 views | jacksinceever |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 08:55 - Feb 2 by latchford |
Penalty and red at that stage and we'd have had three points I have no doubt. |
I think it was a penalty and the ref was yards away. No excuse for him not giving it. If the defender did get the slightest of touches the ref couldn't have seen it and even if he did Tomkins took Bony out first.
We still didn't deserve anything out of the game mind but as you say may have been a different outcome |  | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 11:30 - Feb 2 with 2601 views | Zut_Alors |
They say each game has to be judged equally, but I did wonder whether that Danny Rose tackle played its part. Webb is a strange ref, he's great with the players but his reluctance to make big calls is questionable. This one, however, if it had been Ash sliding in for that one and a pen had been given, there would be plenty complaining. I thought it was a good tackle after seeing the replay back. |  | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 11:50 - Feb 2 with 2563 views | Devz00 |
It was never a penalty. Move on. |  |
| Genetically, paedophiles have more genes in common with crabs than they do with you and me. Now that is scientific fact. There's no real evidence for it, but it is scientific fact. |
| |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 12:11 - Feb 2 with 2524 views | Flashberryjack |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 09:04 - Feb 2 by shandyjack |
correct on all 3 points |
Agree |  |
| |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 12:12 - Feb 2 with 2522 views | jacksinceever |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 11:50 - Feb 2 by Devz00 |
It was never a penalty. Move on. |
It was a penalty. And if we all moved on instead of offering our opinions this board would be pretty dull | | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 19:38 - Feb 2 with 2337 views | bargoedjack |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 12:12 - Feb 2 by jacksinceever |
It was a penalty. And if we all moved on instead of offering our opinions this board would be pretty dull |
Watching it from near the corner flag, it was hard to see exactly what happened. Watching it from Webb's position, you would probably assume that the defender had got the ball from the change of ball direction.
Watching from the goalkeeper's position, from Bony's shoes and the TV replay, it was a stonewall penalty. Tomkins takes out Bony from the side, Bony's foot as he is knocked sends the ball off to his left - obvious pen from there.
Result of it all - instead of being 1-0 up against 10 men, who would then have to chase the game and leave gaps for us to exploit, we lose 2-0 as they give up the wings and plant 9 men inside their D trying to hit us on the occasional counter.
Having said all that, we seemed to lack any sort of clue about how to defend Carroll (and deal with his wrestling technique and height) and also no clue about how to break down 10 "Bigger boys" who pack their spine. |  | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 19:50 - Feb 2 with 2312 views | ploppy |
Wasn't a pen for me. It looked like Tomkins just got the tiniest of touches. Now, if Bony and been a bit more cute and lined himself up to take the shot with his left foot, Tomkins would have had to take him out to get anywhere near the ball. | | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 19:59 - Feb 2 with 2285 views | oldcob |
Webb felt a bit guilty about not awarding penalty. He thought he would even it up by sending off Carrol. If he had given the penalty Carrol would have had no more that a yellow. Anyone believing this isn't how refs minds works is kidding their selves.
 | | | |
| "What a tackle by James Tomkins" on 20:23 - Feb 2 with 2235 views | GrandPrix |
One replay clearly shows Tomkins deflecting the ball in a different direction before touching Bony. No pen for me either |  |
| Good times become good memories......bad times become lessons |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
