 | Forum
Reply | Morgan has his moment but home win continues to elude QPR - Report
at 12:08 24 Oct 2024
There must be more to Celar…surely?
Totally, completely, utterly ineffectual. I found myself feeling sorry for him- just out of his depth. He’s not impressed in any game so far- his positioning, his anticipation, his running on and off the ball ( well maybe once…) , his control. Did he have a shot at goal on Tuesday? No presence.. No aggression .Maybe if he did something that got him booked, I’d warm to him.
At least with Dykes, even when he wasn’t playing well, he was big and an asset when taking and defending corners. Celar hasn’t got the physical presence - well he isn’t that sort of player - the question is what sort of player is he?
We had quite a small team ( in height terms) , without Frey and Madsen noticeable when taking and defending corners .
There must have been something impressive about Celar for us to get him. Or was this faulty analysis by duff data driven software?
Good to see Anderson having a decent part-game. Saito showed he can perform for 90 minutes. Chair is nowhere near his for towards the end of last season.
Found myself thinking of the Jim Smith QPR sides- when did sweeepers go out of fashion? |
| Forum
Reply | It is like giving up smoking....
at 19:15 20 Oct 2024
It’s been worse in the time I’ve been supporting QPR. Alan Mullery’s tenure, the farcical period before Warnock was first appointed are just two. We’ve lost 4 games in a row and haven’t won at home this season.
However…Dembele and Saito are good signings. I agree that Celar has been hugely disappointing so far. Madsen is a bit of an enigma ( which means I don’t have a fuxxxng clue how he’s going to turn out. Maybe he’ll turn out to be a Mike Fillery type or maybe even a John Gregory - dream on…).
It’s still better than it was this time last season. There was no hope under Ainsworth and you could sense he’d lost the players.
That doesn’t appear to be the case now.
So , alright maybe a trifle rose tinted, I think this will be turned around. [Post edited 20 Oct 19:16]
|
| Forum
Reply | Are you Madsen?
at 22:27 19 Oct 2024
He didn’t have a bad first half.He had some decent touches. Didn’t he shoot over the bar in one of our brief pressure periods? [Post edited 19 Oct 22:29]
|
| Forum
Reply | Celar (n/t)
at 22:30 17 Sep 2024
I think that’s right. As a lone striker he doesn’t look comfortable. I’m not familiar with his pre QPR career and what brought the best out of him. His anticipation and positioning suggests he’s still adjusting to the English game generally and the Championship specifically.
Maybe the lad will come good. [Post edited 17 Sep 22:46]
|
| Forum
Thread | Celar
at 21:38 17 Sep 2024
Is he underwhelming or am I missing something?
I’d really like to be impressed but I’m struggling. |
| Forum
Reply | Watch me rise up and leave, all the ashes you made out of me – Report
at 15:22 28 Apr 2024
Great report. Captures the moment.
I’ll just savour this. I’d forgotten that such a performance was possible.
It’s too early to think about next season.A lot can happen. I’m going to keep the optimism bottled up.
For now I’ll settle for the safety that’s been achieved. Huge achievement. |
| Forum
Reply | We are not safe!!!
at 23:22 21 Apr 2024
We are 50.0 on Betfair ( Hudds 1.16,Brum 1.85, SW 2.Ply 7.8, Bburn 8.8, Stoke 70.0).
I think we are overpriced at 50.0 and if I wasn’t emotionally involved I would take that price.
250/1 is crazy |
| Forum
Thread | We are not safe!!!
at 22:50 21 Apr 2024
The premature articulation from many that “ we are safe now” is….err, premature and possibly shows that many Rs supporters can’t add up. We are not out of the shit yet. We need more points , two would do for me , although three would be gilt edged, but my optimism doesn’t run that far.
Wednesday appear to in good shape and Birmingham can be unpredictable.
Blackburn and Plymouth are too close to us. At this stage of the season, strange things happen.
I’m not relaxed, in fact I’m still stressed , wary, apprehensive and very grateful for the Preston keeper. |
| Forum
Reply | “Saint” Marti
at 23:40 7 Apr 2024
Yes Chair, Anderson & Willock together does come across as less than the sum of its parts, with a predictable routine of short passes , followed by more short passes at the edge the box…just felt very ponderous . I guess with Willock being below his best - that Chair - Willock linkup in so many of the early Beale games last season is a distant memory. I feel Willock is so much better when he cuts inside and he looks quite isolated for large periods being so wide. We lack a player like Amos who was good breaking from MF and capitalising on the short passes routines - maybe Hodge could play that role.
The short passes are good and accurate but progress from these at home is slow and ponderous. Maybe that’s one the differences from playing away : we seem less ponderous away from home, playing on the break.
It was very noticeable that SW central midfield functioned better than ours - Hayden’s worst game.
It is a funny game because if we’d taken our chances we’d be commenting differently, more positively. But there’s evidence now that just as we win away typically as a counterattacking team with less possession, that is also how we are undone at Loftus Road by away teams. |
| Forum
Reply | Thoughts post Birmingham
at 10:59 30 Mar 2024
I agree that we were a bit disappointing yesterday ( but that partly is a result of higher expectations).
We are definitely much better now in roles, shape and anticipation when not in possession, but too ponderous, too slow, sometimes in the transition Away from home against over committed sides, breaking through probably easier than at home. I’d like to see Hodge get more time
Although he can’t really be blamed for Bacunas goal, Begovic is becoming a serious liability and does not radiate confidence and that can be catching. |
| Forum
Thread | Thoughts post Birmingham
at 10:22 30 Mar 2024
Looking at our record since Marti took over, If we average points per game, it’s 35 over 25 games or 1.4 points per game.
On that basis we would have 54.6 points ( rather than 43) after 39 games which would make us 10th ( where Middlesbrough currently sit…) and long shots for the playoffs.
So ( deep breath…) assuming we are now going to be safe this season ( I think we need 53 points to be absolutely sure and if we maintain the current points per game ratio we should get there) we only need marginal changes to the squad to become a promotion chasing side.
Impressed by Bacuna yesterday - he stood out in an otherwise poor Birmingham side. Good role model for Armstrong who was surprisingly disappointing ( well…apart from playing a part in setting up THAT goal…)
Should Marti play Anderson, Chair and Willpck together - all players who want a lot of the ball? I’m not sure. I guess a good problem for a manager to have. |
| Forum
Reply | Will 50 points mean safety? Prediction competition
at 18:01 3 Mar 2024
Since Marti took over our record ( in the league) is as follows:
Home W4, D4,L3 ; 11 games, 16 pts ( = 1.45 pts per game)
Away W4, D2, L4; 10 games, 14 pts ( = 1.4 pts per game)
So averaging out at 1.428 pts per game.
If we’d averaged that from the beginning of the season ; ie 35 games so far, we would have had 50 points ( ok 49.98…) . Probably 10th in the table, just a few points off the play offs.
More to the point, if we maintain this average of 1.428 pts per game, we should end up with 53 or 54 points at the end of the season, which I guess would mean not only safety but a reasonably respectable 16th or 17th ( as a reminder last season we ended up 20th with 50 pts). |
| Forum
Reply | Les Ferdinand
at 17:33 30 Dec 2022
So… it’s all Les’ fault that we lost to Luton?
What a load of crap you write : I understand and share the frustration but this kind of “ fan from the heart …bullshit” is such bollocks although sadly inevitable.
Fernandez screwed up badly in the Redknapp and pre Redknapp period. We are still paying the price for that. Les’ appointment brought some stability to the club. He’s doesn’t get everything right but overall he is an asset.
I also like the fact that he’s intelligent and speaks his mind. |
| Forum
Reply | Dozzell
at 13:15 29 Aug 2022
Praise indeed. Yes he does remind me a trifle of the great Mike Fillery…more Fillery than Osborn. |
| | hopekillsyou
|
Site Scores| Forum Votes: | 20 | | Comment Votes: | 4 | | Prediction League: | 0 | | TOTAL: | 24 |
|
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.