By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions. We in turn value your personal details in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Bit early for that, Camp and Smithies were good for us too - DIeng could end up being best since Seaman but lot for him to do before we can say that, been a great start for him at Rangers though no doubt about that.
Bit early for that, Camp and Smithies were good for us too - DIeng could end up being best since Seaman but lot for him to do before we can say that, been a great start for him at Rangers though no doubt about that.
Smithies is the one I'm not sure about. I think he's better than Camp though.
"The opposite of love, after all, is not hate, but indifference."
I said good for us - not that they were world class.
Too early for me with Dieng, in part because he's not playing in front of crowds etc atm, which will be something he's got to deal with later (hopefully) and that will present it's own challenges I guess which the players haven't really had (2K doesn't really count when mostly along way off) since original lockdown in March 2020.
I said good for us - not that they were world class.
Too early for me with Dieng, in part because he's not playing in front of crowds etc atm, which will be something he's got to deal with later (hopefully) and that will present it's own challenges I guess which the players haven't really had (2K doesn't really count when mostly along way off) since original lockdown in March 2020.
Sound. Good point about the crowds.
"The opposite of love, after all, is not hate, but indifference."
In terms of our more modern keepers, I’d have Kenny ahead of Smithies and Dieng. You don’t keep 20+ clean sheets in a championship season without being a bit special.
Not to say that Dieng can’t edge ahead of them both if he keeps playing like this.
Yeah, must not forget Stejskal, my fav keeper after Phil Parkes. According to Wiki there is another Czech GK called Jan Stejskal playing aged 23. I wonder if he is Jan's son? Anyway with a name like that I hope we have scouted him.
Agree that Dieng is looking a wonderful find. I only hope we don't have to sell him soon.
Steyskal was very good, ( and very consistent) , defenders always knew where he was, and which crosses/balls he would go for.
But Parkes was the best QPR keeper in my time, ( just unlucky that their were so many great keepers around at that time, ( Shilton, Clemence, (Banks at Stoke), watched him play for England, Portugal? at Wembley?
Paddy Kenny was also one of the very best,( and will never forget the save against Leicester at home).
In terms of our more modern keepers, I’d have Kenny ahead of Smithies and Dieng. You don’t keep 20+ clean sheets in a championship season without being a bit special.
Not to say that Dieng can’t edge ahead of them both if he keeps playing like this.
Not slagging off Pad who was great for us and I was there ever week for the promotion season.
But Dieng is a better keeper, maybe not a better stopper (where Pad excells) but overall better, and far better in the air.
It's hard comparing players in different eras and teams, the 2011 squad was miles above the 2021 version, Gorkks and Matt Connolly were amazing and we have noone anywhere near Sean Derry in regards of midfield screening. Pad was great and should be remembered as such, but as standalone keepers Seny is better 👌
In terms of our more modern keepers, I’d have Kenny ahead of Smithies and Dieng. You don’t keep 20+ clean sheets in a championship season without being a bit special.
Not to say that Dieng can’t edge ahead of them both if he keeps playing like this.
In our promotion year we'd take the lead and more often as not a few minutes later Paddy Kenny would pull off a fabulous save and keep us in front and yes the rest was as they say history.
I've a huge amount of time and respect for Paddy Kenny's goalkeeping.
"By f ucking heck"
[Post edited 6 Feb 2021 19:22]
My Father had a profound influence on me, he was a lunatic.
Steyskal was very good, ( and very consistent) , defenders always knew where he was, and which crosses/balls he would go for.
But Parkes was the best QPR keeper in my time, ( just unlucky that their were so many great keepers around at that time, ( Shilton, Clemence, (Banks at Stoke), watched him play for England, Portugal? at Wembley?
Paddy Kenny was also one of the very best,( and will never forget the save against Leicester at home).
Phil Parkes' only cap WAS against Portugal but it was in Lisbon. Sir Alf Ramsey's last match. Stan made his debut that night as well.
Best since Smithies for me so far, but I loved Smithies so I may be biased. Its just Dieng is so calm, for the first time since Smithies, I dont lose a month of life every time a ball goes into the box. I even expect him to deal with most things these days. Not too dissimilar in a way to the way I just expected Eze to run rings around teams last year.
Come on mate, he’s great, he may yet be a great, but Kenny was unbelievable and won a promotion here.
Not who done more for QPR but who is a better keeper. And that's Dieng for me, who will probably go for 8-10m in the summer. Paddy was released for free if I remember rightly.
........Not that I'd ever slag Pad as I've mentioned earlier in the thread.
Come on mate, he’s great, he may yet be a great, but Kenny was unbelievable and won a promotion here.
Again, I'm just chatting about talent. Put it this way - who would you buy now, Dieng or 2011 Kenny?
Both are similar in most facets, except for two main things - Kenny has the track record of being a winner which Dieng hasn't as of now, Dieng has the aerial game that Kenny never had.
"The opposite of love, after all, is not hate, but indifference."
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
