Belatedly, the fourth and final part of the annual LFW end of term report on each individual player’s personal contribution during the season. Tonight we assess the strikers.

Djibril  Cisse – D

The French international centre forward could potentially be another reasonably sized stick to beat the club with. Here we have a player that Rangers spent £4m on little over 18 months ago who – when he wasn’t getting ludicrously sent off – seriously looked the part. One of the enduring memories of a traumatic two seasons of Premier League football was peering over the top of my scarf high in the away end at Villa Park in January 2012 as Cisse drew back his foot and pierced the gloom with a fierce volleyed finish into the far corner of the net. His debut was a quarter of an hour old and we were already making Les Ferdinand comparisons. Even his sendings off only seemed to fire him up more for his return.

This continued into a pre-season last summer when QPR spent more time on planes than they did on the training field. Mark Hughes’ side would have been well beaten in Augsburg but for a typically clinical, emphatic two goal salvo from Cisse. An outside each-way bet on him to be the Premier League’s top scorer at odds of 80/1 looked like a reasonable investment rather than folly. Used on his own up front against Swansea on the opening day he struggled in a rank team performance, and then a week later at Norwich when paired with Bobby Zamora he seemed to find the sight of the linesman’s flag arousing – he was flagged 376 times during the second half alone. Dropped for Man City away, then recalled when Andy Johnson’s knee feel apart he lashed one in from fully 30 yards against Reading in the cup. The team was playing poorly, chances were at a premium, but Cisse still looked keen, angry, frustrated and on edge – all the things he was last season when he was at his absolute best. And he still scored whenever he was serviced correctly. Fast forward to January and he put in a performance at West Brom in the cup the likes of which I can scarcely recall. We’ve all accused players of not trying before, but my word his effort levels that night were really something.

So it really depends which way you want to send your pitch fork wielding mob on this one. You could say this was absolutely typical QPR behaviour. They tried to solve long term problems with a short term £4m transfer in the first place, reaped the rewards of the player hitting the ground running and then at the first hint of his form declining bummed him out on loan while spending £8m to replace him with another French striker whose game, like Cisse, is all about pace, power and goals. They could have persevered with a player, coached him back to form, understood that he was going through a divorce in the first half of the season and the potential impact of that – but instead they loaned him out, while no doubt still paying some of his wages, and spent some more money on another very similar player on another big wage.

Or you could say that Cisse has form for this sort of thing. He has never stayed longer than two years on a permanent deal at any club since leaving Liverpool – two years with Marseille, one year with Sunderland, two years with Panathinaikos, six months with Lazio and now 18 months with QPR. He always starts well, frequently scoring on his debut as he did for Rangers, but fades quickly and moves on with another fat signing on fee in his arse pocket. That he decided, at just 31, that he’d rather go out and play loan football for Al Gharafa in the Qatari league should be sounding alarm bells all over the place. Anybody the right side of 36 with any footballing ability at all choosing to go and play there should be written off immediately – particularly somebody like Cisse who rarely gives the impression of being short of cash. This is a part of the world where David O’Leary (David. O’Leary.) was paid £3.3m in compensation having been – yet again – sacked as manager of Al Ahli in the UAE.

That performance at West Brom…

He’s another player I like to be honest. He seems to thrive on having a point to prove, or when he feels he owes somebody something. If we can convince him he owes QPR a bloody good Championship season considering all the money we’ve paid him for relatively little return then he could rip the second tier apart. Of course his wage packet no doubt means we’d offload him at the first hint of any interest whatsoever, but given that he’s spent the last six months playing pat-a-cake football in the desert in front of three Arabs and a sacrificial goat he may find interest from serious players thin on the ground.

Stats:

14 starts, seven sub appearances. W3 D6 L12

Out of Ten: 4,5,7,-, 6,6,6,6,5,5,6,5,4,6,6,6,7,5,6,2,4 = 5.35

Interactive Match Rating: 4.62

Four goals (West Brom H, Reading H league, Reading H cup, Wigan A), 0 assists

Man of the Match Awards – 0

Cards – One yellow (over celebrating)

10 – Adel  Taarabt B

It’s almost instinctive to start any article or review of Adel Taarabt with a point about his attitude. Against West Ham at Loftus Road in September Taarabt, left out of the side for a month by Mark Hughes, sprung from the bench and smacked in an absolute barnburner within ten seconds. After the match he fought back tears during a filmed interview with the club’s official website as he spoke about how he had made an effort with his behaviour and just wanted to play and help the team. In a 1-0 win at Chelsea in January Taarabt played as a lone striker against David Luiz and Branislav Ivanovic and delivered an absolute master class in a role he’d rarely played before. His cute assist, a delicate sideways pass the took all the pace and spin off a dropping ball and teed it up so perfectly even Shaun Wright-Phillips couldn’t miss, executed with a single touch, capped a performance that was as close to perfection as you’ll see in such a situation. In between those two games, against Fulham at home, he tormented Brede Hangeland and won the game with two goals. These weren’t the performances or actions of a man with an attitude problem.

And yet the stories won’t go away: turns up late for training, dreadful attitude, short temper, bad with his team mates, has to be constantly indulged. You can’t talk about indulging his temperament and his young age forever – he’s in danger of being the boy who never grew up. At Stoke, when he was still QPR’s best player, twice he went through on the goal only to try something ridiculously elaborate and miss.

To some extent this is an English disease. We’d far rather have a team of 11 players like Jamie Mackie, who may never do anything technically special but will always try their best, than indulge Adel Taarabt through his inevitable bad days and temper tantrums so that we can enjoy the great times when they do come. I personally think Taarabt did reasonably well during two years in the Premier League in which three different managers frequently dropped him for long periods, and oiks like Joey Barton were allowed to go public with their criticism of him with little comeback. A penalty miss against Norwich just after an interview in the Evening Standard when he spoke about how aware he was of the importance of his performances in the last third of the season to the future of the club seemed to knock his confidence, but he scored and played well at Fulham and Villa away subsequently and finished the season with a hand in ten goals – five scored, five assists – which is a better record than any other player.

I’d like him to stay. He’s shown the damage he can do in the Championship before, he’s worth the admission fee alone when he does play well and that’s not as infrequent as his critics would have you believe. But I don’t think we need Poirot to discover that Harry Redknapp isn’t really his biggest fan. Although the manager has, in the latter stages of his career, preferred a 4-2-3-1 formation which suits Taarabt so well his thinly veiled comments about discipline suggest Taarabt’s time with the club is coming to an end. If so, it will definitely be a case of don’t know what you’ve got until it’s gone.

Stats:

Cards – Five yellows (foul, over celebrating, foul, dissent, over celebrating)

12 – Jamie  Mackie C

There is an accusation that Jamie Mackie – like Clint Hill and Shaun Derry – escapes criticism for poor performances because his attitude is good and he tries hard. I think that’s true to some extent, and if the team was performing well and halfway up the Premier League then to be keeping a sub-standard player in simply because he’s a nice lad would hinder progress. But when you’re in the situation that QPR are in, with a squad chock full of underperforming, over paid, under committed mercenaries, you need as many people like Mackie, Derry and Hill as you can get in the team because even when they’re playing poorly, they’re still doing more good than the likes of Jose Bosingwa.

To begin the season I thought Mackie was playing well. He was picked as a lone striker at home to Aston Villa and scored a fine headed goal. Against Norwich at Loftus Road his hard running won a penalty when many of his team mates would never have run into the situation in the first place. In injury time at Arsenal, with Rangers down by a goal and reduced to ten men, he set off on a run that carried him past three tackles and could have resulted in the Goal of the Season but for a fine save. Again, his critics will say that I’m praising the run when with another player I’d be criticising him for the miss and it certainly wasn’t the only good chance Mackie missed – starting with a sitter against Swansea on day one which would have made it 1-1 had it been scored.

He seemed to lose heart and confidence in the second half of the season. That could be because of his poor form in front of goal, although given that hasn’t affected him before in his time with the club I’m not sure that’s it. The whole situation at the club, and Harry Redknapp’s decision that he was going to be little more than a last-resort impact sub while the likes of Bosingwa and Granero were given regular outings despite poor performances and appalling effort levels, seemed to get him down. His season concluded with him firing a great chance for an equaliser at Liverpool high over the bar and his body language rather said it all. His goals and assists total (two/zero) is simply not good enough – Jay Bothroyd managed more of both from seven appearances.

Personally I think he should have been kept in the team. I don’t see that he would have done any worse than Junior Hoilett and he’d have cared about what he was doing a lot more. Like Faurlin, Diakite, DJ Campbell and several others he’s potentially a great player for QPR in the Championship that Redknapp doesn’t seem to have a lot of time for.

Stats:

21 starts and 12 sub appearances. W4, D12, L17

Out of Ten: 4,6,6,6,5,5,6,5,7,8,7,8,6,6,5,5,4,7,5,6,7,5,5,6,4,4,7.-.-.-.5.-.6 = 5.72

Interactive Match Rating: 5.01

Two goals (Villa H, Man Utd A), zero asissts

Man of the Match Awards – Two (Villa H, Man Utd A)

Cards – Two yellows (foul, foul)

18 – Loic  Remy B

When Tony Fernandes writes his life story, I wonder if the Loic Remy episode may turn out to be the moment he realised he’d made a mistake getting involved in the ludicrous world of football.

This was surely a failsafe transfer, and one Fernandes worked so hard on personally to ensure QPR beat Newcastle to the signature. A French international, aged just 26, who would either come in and score the goals to keep QPR up or, if the club was relegated, be easy to shift on for exactly what Rangers paid to get him. It seemed like a no-lose situation, and looked like turning out that way. QPR were dreadful and deserved to finish last and crash out of the Premier League, but it certainly wasn’t for want of trying on Remy’s part. An early interview where he compared himself to a finely tuned Rolls Royce – awesome in full flight but easily side-lined if something isn’t quite right – put the amber warning light on and sure enough after marching through on the goal at Upton Park and calmly opening his time at QPR with an early goal he then missed key matches with a groin injury. But Remy returned, played regularly and superbly long after the rest of his team mates had given up – there were goals at Southampton and Fulham and a clear Goal of the Season winner at home to Wigan struck as purely as you’ll ever see a football hit. When he played you thought QPR might score, when he didn’t you knew they wouldn’t. He looked like everything Arsenal and Tottenham were missing and so despite the relegation it looked like the second part of the master plan was still very firmly in place. With Remy now proven in the Premier League, Rangers readied themselves for a queue of suitors stretching round Batman Close.

What has actually transpired is secret option number three – what is fast becoming known as ‘The QPR factor’. What the club hadn’t banked on was Remy becoming embroiled in a criminal investigation into an allegation of gang rape that, rather inconveniently, now includes bail that stretches until one day after the transfer window closes. So now QPR have a striker that may be legally precluded from moving to a foreign country, who could potentially be jailed for a considerable length of time in the not too distant future. You’d have to be fairly flash with your money to commit £8m to that. Rangers are seemingly now restricted to taking a vastly reduced offer from a chancer or – yet again – loaning out a senior player with a view to a permanent move further down the tracks. Remy meanwhile is limited to said loan spell, starting World Cup year in the Championship, or hoping that the charges come to nothing in time for him to catch the tail end of the extended transfer windows in the refuse skips of European football – Russia and Turkey.

So the only two January signings who could be counted as a success - Andros Townsend and Loic Remy – now have a four month ban for illegal betting on matches, and a rape accusation between them. We’re Queens Park Rangers, we fuck your career.

Stats:

Cards – one yellow (foul)

25 – Bobby  Zamora D

The striker and Martin Jol clearly don’t get on, and he’s had a difficult relationship with supporters at West Ham, Fulham and now Queens Park Rangers. That, I believe, is because quite often Zamora will play well within himself, and that’s frustrating when you’ve seen him do much better. I’ve seen Bobby Zamora have some wonderful games and really lead a team from the front, but I’ve come to the conclusion that he only seems to really put his back into his work when he thinks there’s something there for him. It’s no surprise, for instance, that he always seems to play well for all his clubs against Arsenal – because since Sol Campbell gave up the ghost Arsene Wenger has stubbornly stuck with slighter, more technical centre backs and Zamora knows he can dominate them. When the going is tougher, Zamora sort of hangs a leg in here and there and not a lot else.

Being left out at the beginning of the season seemed to fire him up and he was very decent in mediocre team performances against Norwich and Man City to begin with. He’s got a hold up and lay game that nobody at the club can match since Heidar Helguson left, and given that Zamora subsequently spent the rest of the season either out injured or playing injured that decision to let the Icelandic veteran go to Cardiff on a free was among the worst the club made this term. Had Zamora and Helguson been able to share the workload QPR may have made a better fist of things. Instead, without Zamora, Rangers were at times reduced to picking Jamie Mackie or Adel Taarabt alone up front and the ball just doesn’t stick in such situations.

When Zamora did return to action we found that he was unable to play for longer than a half because his hip allegedly seized up at half time. Redknapp sent him out after the break regardless and so we had the utterly farcical situation for several games where Zamora was limping around just trying to get in the way a bit. In the second half at Swansea away you could perhaps see why Redknapp was so keen to get his target man out there, but the headers he won in the second half of the season can be counted on the fingers of one hand. A newspaper article, apparently misquoted, in which he claimed not to really like football did him few favours at a bad time in the season. Considering he managed to get his leg up high enough to boot Jordi Gomez in the face and get sent off in a crucial home match with Wigan I wonder just how injured his bloody hip really was – but I’ve been told off for a lack of tolerance with injury prone players before so I’ll hold my tongue.

I’m worried about Zamora. I take what Harry Redknapp says with lorry loads of salt and I suspect – hope – that his constant reference to not being able to get Zamora into the team often enough as a prime reason for relegation is just another attempt to shift attention away from other decisions he’s made. If fully fit and motivated Zamora would have made a big difference to QPR, but he wouldn’t have kept them up. If you take Redknapp at his word he seems to be pinning his hopes next season on Zamora leading the front line for a season in which QPR will play Saturday-Tuesday-Saturday most weeks and have at least 48 games. There was even a story that said as Zamora’s hip surgery would keep him out for a year and he only has 12 months left on his contract they’re going to delay it and go through next season as they finished the last, nursing him through to about the hour mark in games and then substituting him.

I’ll be watching through my fingers if that’s the case. The whole thing looks like a potential disaster or, if you want to be cynical, a ready-made Redknapp excuse if things don’t go well.

Stats:

Cards – One red (Wigan H, serious foul play), one yellow (foul)

37 – Jay  Bothroyd N/A

Although neither Jay Bothroyd nor DJ Campbell have played enough football for QPR this season to be graded, there seemed to be a little too much to say about both to bung them in the ‘others’ section at the bottom.

Bothroyd remains an enormously frustrating player. At West Brom in the FA Cup Third Round replay he was a clear man of the match, scoring the winning goal and giving the Baggies problems all evening. When subsequently picked up front for a key game at Southampton he scored again and played reasonably well. And while on loan at Sheffield Wednesday those who tuned in for a bad tempered Friday night clash against Leeds will have seen him looking lively and threatening all evening and, again, scoring the winner.

And yet most of the time Bothroyd looks and plays like somebody who has been popping sleeping pills mistaking them for Pro-Plus. When his West Brom performance earned him a league outing at West Ham he looked like he’d donned concrete boots to mark the occasion. He has an ambling style which could well in fact just be laziness and a bizarre aversion – considering he’s supposed to be a striker - to getting himself into the heart of the penalty area. More often than not you’ll find him withdrawing deep onto the right wing which not only crowds the space out there for the winger to operate in, but also means that when either of them have the ball they’re looking up and seeing an empty penalty box. I remember a game in 2011/12 where Joey Barton put in a half decent cross and then gave Bothroyd – who was standing outside the penalty area when the ball went in – the rounds of the kitchen for not being in there. Bothroyd sort of laughed and shrugged, assuming that it was just Barton being Barton when in actual fact it was one of the rare occasions when the midfielder was right.

Perhaps Bothroyd thinks this sitting deep and withdrawing wide makes him elusive and difficult to track, but then given his recent brushes with the traffic police and dodgy lethal-weapon themed tattoo it’s a stretch to believe that Jay Bothroyd thinks that deeply about anything. Potentially useful for QPR in the Championship but given that, apart from the Leeds game, he was absolutely woeful for Sheffield Wednesday while on loan there last season and hated by their fans I wouldn’t go raising any hopes too high just yet.

Stats:

14 starts, one goal, for Sheff Wed

39 – DJ  Campbell N/A

DJ Campbell is another who played the vast majority of his football out on loan last season and as we stand today it’s not clear whether he’s going to be at QPR next season or not. Given one of his temporary spells yielded ten goals from 17 starts in a fairly lousy Ipswich Town team it’s reasonable to think that not only would DJ Campbell have been rather more use to QPR than a measly two starts in the FA Cup suggest, but that he could well be a key figure for the R’s in the Championship next season. It would however be remiss, having criticised Bobby Zamora and Armand Traore for their fitness, not to point out that Campbell has been injured for the vast majority of his two years with QPR, including the second half of this season when he was loaned out to Blackburn and only played seven times.

Campbell is currently stuck in a state of flux where the club don’t seem very sure whether they’re releasing him or not. In my opinion they should be signing him up as quickly as possible and aiming to start next season with him as first choice. When fit he will score goals in the Championship and he proved that last year with Ipswich. Throw in the fact that he’s a QPR fan and will want to do well for the club and it’s an added attraction. Assuming that Djibril Cisse and Loic Remy will be leaving, and considering the physical state of Bobby Zamora and Andy Johnson, I think he’s a good option for us.

If DJ Campbell had just been released by another club I’d suggest there would be a fair old clamour for QPR to be looking at him. If we are going to release him I don’t think there will be any shortage of Championship interest and I fear him scoring regularly for one of our rivals next season while we struggle for goals and lament ever letting him go. I’d like to see him signed on and started regularly for the first time in his time with Rangers.

Stats:

Five starts, two sub appearances, no goals for Blackburn

Others >>> Andy Johnson was the best Fulham player on the pitch at Loftus Road last season and I wasn’t as dead set against his signing as many others back in the summer. Sadly, his recent fitness record is a mile long and after an encouraging performance against Man City his knee fell apart against Chelsea and he hasn’t played again since. Potentially superb in the Championship, but relying on him again would be a risky business.

A quartet of perennially loaned out strikers - Rob Hulse, Bruno Andrade, Angelo Balanta and Troy Hewitt - all failed to impress on their temporary spells away from the club. Hulse in particular, one of the Championships leading strikers just a couple of years ago, looks like a man who couldn’t care less if he never plays football again. The sort of player Sheffield United might come after – he’d certainly be very fortunate to get an offer in the second tier.

Tweet @loftforwords Pictures – Action Images

Photo: Action Images

Kaos_Agent added 06:15 - Jun 17 Thanks for the final installment Clive. More grim reading. I hope Remy plays for us next year because if he doesn't then who knows where the goals will come from, given that Adel is out of favour and that the other striker options are not very convincing. Let's see now. Thin on strikers. Inconsistent midfielders who generally don't provide service. Questions on defense and in goal. Morale and cohesiveness low. Things are certainly looking up for the Championship. Harry's biggest challenge may be yet to come.

0

MelakaRanger added 07:54 - Jun 17 Its crazy We have on our books and under contract players that would score plenty of goals for us next year. But will any of them play for us or want to play for us? Remy - £8million buy out clause and £60K a week wages who will not want to play in the Championship in World Cup year. Cisse - proven goal score who seems a) out of favor with Harry and b) doesnt seem to want to play fo us anymore but out of favor with Harry DJ - Proven goal score in the Championship If we had these 3 in our squad, and wanting to play for us, next season forget all the others. We would be banging in goals left right and centre. If we brought in someone like say Jordan Rhodes then surely that would almost certainly assure us of a top 2 finish. But, most probably we will end up with just Zamaora and Johnson as our spearhead in attack and the other 3 off scoring for others Bummer!

0

ngbqpr added 09:44 - Jun 17 The saddest thing about these reviews is all have been articulatimg so well what so many of us have felt week in week out over the last 18 months...but in Hughes & Redknapp we've had two managers both (allegedly) in the top 20 earners in the WORLD in their chosen profession who have both failed to see so many things that seem bleedin' obvious to us, the fans Yes it's a workplace and we only see the players for a couple of hours a week - but isn't that what managers do - make the workplace function? Hughes just seemed plain deluded. Redknapp just seems to enjoy the circus without being too worried about the outcome as long as he can blame factors beyond his control. What a mess

0

rodneeranger added 11:03 - Jun 17 'We are QPR; we f... your career.' I beg to differ. He f..... his own career. Nothing at all with being a QPR player.
0

dixiedean added 11:21 - Jun 17 agree with Rodneeranger - QPR didn't F*** Up anything with any of these blokes, they did it themselves ( although I suspect your comment was tongue-in-cheek ) But as Clive said many times re Adel in the Championship season, if these guys weren't flawed characters in some respect they certainly would have signed for someone a lot better than us, so up to a point we have to indulge them. How good with Adel be if he had Shearer's dedication ? But Rangers have always had mavericks and that's why we're QPR and a large reason why most of us support the R's in the first place. So the common denominator is we have a pre-disposition to signing a certain type of player, rather than something inherent in the club which sends them off the rails.It would be nice to have the occasional ' normal ' bloke around though !

0

albiceleste added 11:30 - Jun 17 it s a worry if it is QPR the club causing the rush of blood in the personal behaviour of Remy, Bothroyd and Townsend... I think these problems are rather more wide spread across football in general What is the solution? Good honest work horses? The club is stuck with contracts that are not helpful, making for a Heath Robinson collection of mis fits, luxury items and odd balls. Not optimistic for next season ....

0

Northernr added 12:35 - Jun 17 Yeh, what Dixie said. When a player is doing something daft it does always seem to be one of our players doesn't it? Hence the tongue in cheek remark in Remy's piece.
0

HastingsRanger added 14:57 - Jun 17 Thanks Clive. What disturbs me most is that when you name the best 11, and a handful of subs, playing as they should, we have a team that could be safe in the Premiership. This same team rightly finished a long way off the mark and I see no reason to things changing in the Championship. Egotistical players and player rifts have played their part. Players who we can't shift will play their part going forward and worryingly there seems to be management team that seems to be losing (or throwing away) the dressing room. This no longer seems a summer clear out but more of a rebuilding from the ground upwards. A season like the Holloway's first in the 3rd tier with signing of committed players or supporters (e.g. DJ), who give a damn for us or their career path - I don't mind which. Without this, frankly Championship survival is the best I can see next season, just a couple of days and we will know who will we have in the last game!!

0

extratimeR added 23:10 - Jun 17 Thanks Clive Cisse Yes, I was sitting on the half way line surrounded by Villa fans when he scored that terrific goal, and forgot where I was sitting, (not clever), but survived to tell the tale. He was terrific that night, (as were the team in the first half), I wont forget him pushing the ball round their (Irish?), centre half and skinning him, before he went off knackered. I thought hello we've cracked it!

0

Myke added 00:28 - Jun 18 Great summary Clive - so frustrating to have good strikers (Campbell, Helguson ) playing and scoring for other teams last season. I said at the time that we should have held onto Cisse even when buying Remy, so we would have one of them available every game. Really disappointed with Mackie last season - thought with his goals the previous season v Blackburn and City that he would have kicked on, but unlike Derry and Hill ( and totally out of character to be fair) he seemed to give up. Nit-picking here Clive ( don't even rate the bloke) but did Zamora not also score at Man City?

0

rodneeranger added 07:24 - Jun 18 I'm afraid I'm getting more and more worried about 'Arry. He seems to dislike the players I like (I know it's only my opinion) and keep playing the ones I can't stand. In the latter category, I put that clown Bosingwa, who after his refusal to sit on the bench, should never again have been allowed to don a QPR shirt! In the first category, I'd put Faurlin, loaned out when he could still have done a decent job for us. Adel nearly always shows his class, yet obviously 'Arry can't stand him. And as for the insistence to play Park, who runs around like a headless chicken and often falls over his own feet!, is just incomprehensible. With these facts in mind, I fear for next season, but wait in hope.

0

delhisuperhoop added 12:36 - Jun 19 Totally agree about DJ. I cannot understand why he doesn't start more often or why we are still uncertain about the plans for him
0

Blogs 31 bloggers

Bristol City Polls