| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 09:12 - Dec 12 with 2241 views | Thornburyswan |
Decent article that Keith, nice job. |  | |  |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 09:27 - Dec 12 with 2184 views | NotLoyal |
Precise as ever, and a warning or two in there for Russell Martin. |  |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 09:35 - Dec 12 with 2159 views | 34dfgdf54 |
We won’t sack him, we have invested too much to sack him this early but I can’t see us getting anything next two games, slump setting in.
It has been poor, that yesterday was shocking and can’t be excused. |  | | |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 09:43 - Dec 12 with 2148 views | Catullus |
We wont sack him? No matter what? I'm not sure that's true. lets see what season ticket sales do, lets see if attendances drop off, lets see if we slip into the relegation zone.
We can say something won't happen but it always depends on the reality of the situation. If we slip into the drop zone over Christmas and New year I'm sure it'll focus the owners thinking. Can we afford a relegation and the subsequent drop in income.
Certainly something has to change and that is entirely down to Russell martin right now. He needs to do better with what he's got. | |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 09:49 - Dec 12 with 2133 views | KeithHaynes |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 09:43 - Dec 12 by Catullus |
We wont sack him? No matter what? I'm not sure that's true. lets see what season ticket sales do, lets see if attendances drop off, lets see if we slip into the relegation zone.
We can say something won't happen but it always depends on the reality of the situation. If we slip into the drop zone over Christmas and New year I'm sure it'll focus the owners thinking. Can we afford a relegation and the subsequent drop in income.
Certainly something has to change and that is entirely down to Russell martin right now. He needs to do better with what he's got. |
It’s all about January, not no matter what 😉 |  |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 09:51 - Dec 12 with 2120 views | Dr_Parnassus |
Good article with some nice balance.
Sacking him shouldn’t be on the cards right now. An intervention might be though.
I can absolutely see the benefit of a collaborative meeting where the club, the players and the management staff can work towards a common goal of playing a certain way which is attractive and yet achievable as well as successful.
I’m not sure I like the whole, “we must play this exact way and not deviate no matter the consequence” sort of mantra that appears to be going on. It’s just brainless.
Surely there is a smarter way to go about this if everyone is in agreement that we don’t have the tools to do this successfully? His job is literally to manage these situations, not just bulldoze through them.
It feels like a cutting off the nose to spite the face type vibe there at the moment, which isn’t a good atmosphere for breeding success… or trust. |  |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 10:11 - Dec 12 with 2069 views | onehunglow |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 09:51 - Dec 12 by Dr_Parnassus |
Good article with some nice balance.
Sacking him shouldn’t be on the cards right now. An intervention might be though.
I can absolutely see the benefit of a collaborative meeting where the club, the players and the management staff can work towards a common goal of playing a certain way which is attractive and yet achievable as well as successful.
I’m not sure I like the whole, “we must play this exact way and not deviate no matter the consequence” sort of mantra that appears to be going on. It’s just brainless.
Surely there is a smarter way to go about this if everyone is in agreement that we don’t have the tools to do this successfully? His job is literally to manage these situations, not just bulldoze through them.
It feels like a cutting off the nose to spite the face type vibe there at the moment, which isn’t a good atmosphere for breeding success… or trust. |
The reason being financial then not football.That is evident so let's be honet.Many would love to see him replaced right now before he doe everlasting damage BUT we cannot afford too. Good work by the Board then.
He is full of excuses and empty of ideas
Players should approach him led by our captain | |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 10:19 - Dec 12 with 2064 views | Dr_Parnassus |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 10:11 - Dec 12 by onehunglow |
The reason being financial then not football.That is evident so let's be honet.Many would love to see him replaced right now before he doe everlasting damage BUT we cannot afford too. Good work by the Board then.
He is full of excuses and empty of ideas
Players should approach him led by our captain |
Both really, financially it would not be a good idea and in terms of football we have already struck upon a nice style that we know we can play and we know is successful.
Martin needs a metaphorical kick up the backside to ditch the ego and go back to what we evolved into after painful trial and error, whether it was how he envisioned us playing at the start or not shouldn’t be a factor - he needs to be adaptable, it’s management.
It was a fantastic balance and it worked.
It does feel like a slap in the face that we continue to sacrifice results for our club in order to satisfy this maddening obsession with a way of playing that clearly doesn’t work and hasn’t worked anywhere he’s been. | |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 10:24 - Dec 12 with 2056 views | Catullus |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 09:49 - Dec 12 by KeithHaynes |
It’s all about January, not no matter what 😉 |
How about, "all about January no matter what"
Realistically, what does Martin need and how much will it cost?
My opinion, we need a new keeper, at least one CB, 2 wide players be they wing backs or proper wingers and at least one more striker. So 5 players, can we afford all that in January?
Haven't the owners already said for new players to come in, the wage bill needs to be trimmed? What if nobody wants any of our players (that we want rid of) so we can't trim the wages? Nobody particularly wanted Grimes last window, something that I am now very much regretting again.
Of our first 11 I can only see anybody fancying the players we'd want to keep, Piroe, Downes, Ntcham, anybody else?
The next window could be make or break for Martin, if not from the owners perspective, maybe from the fans point of view.
Surely everyone agrees we cannot keep on playing like we did yesterday? Pointless possession, pointless passing, lazy players as you said yourself. | |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 10:28 - Dec 12 with 2044 views | KeithHaynes |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 10:24 - Dec 12 by Catullus |
How about, "all about January no matter what"
Realistically, what does Martin need and how much will it cost?
My opinion, we need a new keeper, at least one CB, 2 wide players be they wing backs or proper wingers and at least one more striker. So 5 players, can we afford all that in January?
Haven't the owners already said for new players to come in, the wage bill needs to be trimmed? What if nobody wants any of our players (that we want rid of) so we can't trim the wages? Nobody particularly wanted Grimes last window, something that I am now very much regretting again.
Of our first 11 I can only see anybody fancying the players we'd want to keep, Piroe, Downes, Ntcham, anybody else?
The next window could be make or break for Martin, if not from the owners perspective, maybe from the fans point of view.
Surely everyone agrees we cannot keep on playing like we did yesterday? Pointless possession, pointless passing, lazy players as you said yourself. |
It’s probably all about what comes at the end of March ‘ no matter what ‘
That will be his first reckoning. | |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 10:39 - Dec 12 with 2030 views | dobjack2 |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 09:49 - Dec 12 by KeithHaynes |
It’s all about January, not no matter what 😉 |
Good article.
If Martin gets players with the skill sets he requires then we continue as we are and hopefully develop further. If not then he has to consider a rethink until he can get them. Is he asking too much of the players at a club without the money to get the players he needs or can coach to play the way he wants?
The vast majority of us don't know what is going on behind the scenes but for whatever reason, some players are not part of Martin's plans. To get the players he wants players are going to leave.
The article highlights where we are most vulnerable and that all concerned with coaching and recruitment know that. The next window is key for Martin going forward. He wants to play a system that is demanding of players physically, skill wise and mentally. Currently players in key positions don't appear to be up to it. | | | |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 10:40 - Dec 12 with 2018 views | onehunglow |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 10:19 - Dec 12 by Dr_Parnassus |
Both really, financially it would not be a good idea and in terms of football we have already struck upon a nice style that we know we can play and we know is successful.
Martin needs a metaphorical kick up the backside to ditch the ego and go back to what we evolved into after painful trial and error, whether it was how he envisioned us playing at the start or not shouldn’t be a factor - he needs to be adaptable, it’s management.
It was a fantastic balance and it worked.
It does feel like a slap in the face that we continue to sacrifice results for our club in order to satisfy this maddening obsession with a way of playing that clearly doesn’t work and hasn’t worked anywhere he’s been. |
Obsession it is.
Cab Bennett Cooper are capable enough as CH but are no full backs.
Naughton is a half decent full back but no CH,and DOWNES i a fine midfielder but dear God -a Centre Half.
Have defenders defend,goalkeeper just save shots and forget trying to be Messi | |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 11:03 - Dec 12 with 2010 views | max936 |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 09:49 - Dec 12 by KeithHaynes |
It’s all about January, not no matter what 😉 |
Giving the hapless Martin more money to spend, is like chucking money in the Tawe and watching it float away. |  |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 11:14 - Dec 12 with 1996 views | max936 |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 10:24 - Dec 12 by Catullus |
How about, "all about January no matter what"
Realistically, what does Martin need and how much will it cost?
My opinion, we need a new keeper, at least one CB, 2 wide players be they wing backs or proper wingers and at least one more striker. So 5 players, can we afford all that in January?
Haven't the owners already said for new players to come in, the wage bill needs to be trimmed? What if nobody wants any of our players (that we want rid of) so we can't trim the wages? Nobody particularly wanted Grimes last window, something that I am now very much regretting again.
Of our first 11 I can only see anybody fancying the players we'd want to keep, Piroe, Downes, Ntcham, anybody else?
The next window could be make or break for Martin, if not from the owners perspective, maybe from the fans point of view.
Surely everyone agrees we cannot keep on playing like we did yesterday? Pointless possession, pointless passing, lazy players as you said yourself. |
He sent Joseph out without giving him a chance and that after we spent nearly a million on him. | |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 11:17 - Dec 12 with 1991 views | jackrabbit |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 11:03 - Dec 12 by max936 |
Giving the hapless Martin more money to spend, is like chucking money in the Tawe and watching it float away. |
I think that’s a bit unfair - Piroe, Ntcham and Paterson, to mention just 3, have been good acquisitions. More of the same quality we need. |  | | |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 11:24 - Dec 12 with 1966 views | max936 |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 11:17 - Dec 12 by jackrabbit |
I think that’s a bit unfair - Piroe, Ntcham and Paterson, to mention just 3, have been good acquisitions. More of the same quality we need. |
Its Martin himself that's the problem, not the players, are those players gonna want to stay the way we are at the moment, he peed Piroe off before the season even started, he's done same to others as well, I have no doubts about that. | |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 11:54 - Dec 12 with 1925 views | KeithHaynes |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 11:03 - Dec 12 by max936 |
Giving the hapless Martin more money to spend, is like chucking money in the Tawe and watching it float away. |
Fortunately it isn’t down to him, in most cases. | |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 12:00 - Dec 12 with 1919 views | Catullus |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 11:14 - Dec 12 by max936 |
He sent Joseph out without giving him a chance and that after we spent nearly a million on him. |
How is Joseph doing? Maybe we need to recall him and give him a go?
I'm all for possession based football, but possession with a point. The regression (or drop in form) in the last few weeks has been startling. Grimes reverting to type, Pato has been awful, players played out of position and getting skinned, the keeper making self destructive mistakes and gifting goals.
It's not about sacking Martin, it's about Martin being realistic with what this squad can consistently do to a decent standard. If Martin cannot or will not change, where are we going?
On that point, I concede the ground to Dr P, if Martin persists with this style "no matter what" then we are heading for trouble.
I also concede ground to OHL, you may be right, Martin may be too full of himself to accept he could be wrong.
This Christmas period and January window is massive for our club. | |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 12:38 - Dec 12 with 1871 views | max936 |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 12:00 - Dec 12 by Catullus |
How is Joseph doing? Maybe we need to recall him and give him a go?
I'm all for possession based football, but possession with a point. The regression (or drop in form) in the last few weeks has been startling. Grimes reverting to type, Pato has been awful, players played out of position and getting skinned, the keeper making self destructive mistakes and gifting goals.
It's not about sacking Martin, it's about Martin being realistic with what this squad can consistently do to a decent standard. If Martin cannot or will not change, where are we going?
On that point, I concede the ground to Dr P, if Martin persists with this style "no matter what" then we are heading for trouble.
I also concede ground to OHL, you may be right, Martin may be too full of himself to accept he could be wrong.
This Christmas period and January window is massive for our club. |
He was doing ok, but my point is about Martin not giving the boy a chance he's got the pace that we desperately need and did need since start of the season and yet he hoofed him out, | |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 14:38 - Dec 12 with 1788 views | Catullus |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 12:38 - Dec 12 by max936 |
He was doing ok, but my point is about Martin not giving the boy a chance he's got the pace that we desperately need and did need since start of the season and yet he hoofed him out, |
Maybe we need Joseph back and play a front 3 of Joseph, Piroe and Whittaker!
At least there'd be some pace. | |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 14:44 - Dec 12 with 1780 views | max936 |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 14:38 - Dec 12 by Catullus |
Maybe we need Joseph back and play a front 3 of Joseph, Piroe and Whittaker!
At least there'd be some pace. |
Lets at least have that option. | |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 15:26 - Dec 12 with 1746 views | onehunglow |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 14:44 - Dec 12 by max936 |
Lets at least have that option. |
We lack pace. Hence we go backwards led by Grimes as slow a player as we ve had .
Joseph is quick as is Garrick and Whittaker .
Piroe will score .
We just need to reset
Why not Cooper Bennett Cabango
Neuton and Manning [sadly] as full backs
Have Downes Fulton Ncham as a midfield
Piroe and Obefemi or Pato.
The players are there | |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 16:25 - Dec 12 with 1711 views | howenjack |
All good successful teams have a consistent unchanged back 4 (injuries/suspensions) permitting.The more they play together the more the instinctive knowledge of where their teamates are at any point in a game situation grows. Its not possible to do this as much in midfield admittedly because there is more running involved and fatigue /strains are more prevalent neccesitating more rotation. At the moment playing in the back 4 at Swansea is like a game of musical chairs. There is an old adage _ If it aint broke dont fix it . Unfortunately the manager has been fixing things that aren't broken.
Bill Shankley was once asked what the team would be for Saturdays match He replied "Its the same as last year". One of the key ingredients of Liverpools success - Less is more. | | | |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 16:27 - Dec 12 with 1706 views | KeithHaynes |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 16:25 - Dec 12 by howenjack |
All good successful teams have a consistent unchanged back 4 (injuries/suspensions) permitting.The more they play together the more the instinctive knowledge of where their teamates are at any point in a game situation grows. Its not possible to do this as much in midfield admittedly because there is more running involved and fatigue /strains are more prevalent neccesitating more rotation. At the moment playing in the back 4 at Swansea is like a game of musical chairs. There is an old adage _ If it aint broke dont fix it . Unfortunately the manager has been fixing things that aren't broken.
Bill Shankley was once asked what the team would be for Saturdays match He replied "Its the same as last year". One of the key ingredients of Liverpools success - Less is more. |
Different times but Harris / Walker. | |
| |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 16:45 - Dec 12 with 1686 views | Boundy |
| The realistic response to sacking Swansea City manager Russell Martin on 15:26 - Dec 12 by onehunglow |
We lack pace. Hence we go backwards led by Grimes as slow a player as we ve had .
Joseph is quick as is Garrick and Whittaker .
Piroe will score .
We just need to reset
Why not Cooper Bennett Cabango
Neuton and Manning [sadly] as full backs
Have Downes Fulton Ncham as a midfield
Piroe and Obefemi or Pato.
The players are there |
I think you'll find Cooper is even slower the Cabango , who had no protection what so ever yesterday | |
| "In a free society, the State is the servant of the people—not the master." |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
