| if our U23s played our first team... 23:47 - Dec 26 with 6677 views | paulv2k4 |
...would they win??
i have never watched the U23s other than in our highlights (where they seem quite good) but do the people in the know think they would beat our current first 11?
i just wondered if we should start giving them a go. [Post edited 27 Dec 2017 19:04]
|  | | |  |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 00:00 - Dec 27 with 5555 views | Wanderer |
George Byers for one |  | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 00:08 - Dec 27 with 5549 views | Wanderer |
On a separate note, with De Boer and Berkgamp being mentioned in the press, what happened to the dutch wonder kid we signed from Ajax a couple of months back? is he going okay? | | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 00:25 - Dec 27 with 5514 views | Swanjaxs |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 00:08 - Dec 27 by Wanderer |
On a separate note, with De Boer and Berkgamp being mentioned in the press, what happened to the dutch wonder kid we signed from Ajax a couple of months back? is he going okay? |
He's working in Morrison's on a zero hour contract now apparently.... |  |
| |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 00:43 - Dec 27 with 5497 views | jasper_T |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 00:08 - Dec 27 by Wanderer |
On a separate note, with De Boer and Berkgamp being mentioned in the press, what happened to the dutch wonder kid we signed from Ajax a couple of months back? is he going okay? |
Kees de Boer is 17, and he was released by them so hardly a wonderkid.
He's been doing okay for the u18s afaik. | | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 05:08 - Dec 27 with 5438 views | EU5Makaveli |
I've watched them a few times and I'm sorry to say none of them are anywhere near the required standard.
Honestly there's a few players in there with a chance of becoming decent championship players (Byers, Rodon, James, Gorre) just to name a few.
But premier league? Absolutely no chance in all honesty. |  | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 06:22 - Dec 27 with 5394 views | Kilkennyjack |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 05:08 - Dec 27 by EU5Makaveli |
I've watched them a few times and I'm sorry to say none of them are anywhere near the required standard.
Honestly there's a few players in there with a chance of becoming decent championship players (Byers, Rodon, James, Gorre) just to name a few.
But premier league? Absolutely no chance in all honesty. |
True.
Kenji Gorre is 23.
Same age as Alfie Mawson.
Shirley he should be playing first team, or got rid.
James and Byers are both bought in players, so thank feck for big Joe.
The academy remains a big failure. |  |
| Beware of the Risen People
|
| |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 06:58 - Dec 27 with 5373 views | Jackfath |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 06:22 - Dec 27 by Kilkennyjack |
True.
Kenji Gorre is 23.
Same age as Alfie Mawson.
Shirley he should be playing first team, or got rid.
James and Byers are both bought in players, so thank feck for big Joe.
The academy remains a big failure. |
I agree.
Some of the players who play for that side are robbing a living. Why would any professional want to play week in week out for that side? Surely you'd want to back yourself and move on to turn out for a div 1/div 2 side and build your rep.
It's far too comfortable there for them. Huge salaries for not doing too much at all. |  |
| |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 07:28 - Dec 27 with 5341 views | paulv2k4 |
thanks for the insight guys.
thats a worry then, our "envious academy" isn't producing anything.
wont help much when we get relegated | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| if our U23s played our first team... on 07:36 - Dec 27 with 5332 views | Jackfath |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 07:28 - Dec 27 by paulv2k4 |
thanks for the insight guys.
thats a worry then, our "envious academy" isn't producing anything.
wont help much when we get relegated |
It will as many of those players will then be deemed good enough. All part of the master plan. | |
| |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 15:06 - Dec 27 with 5167 views | jasper_T |
Byers, Roberts, McBurnie and James have the potential to be useful squad players in the Championsip next season. Rodon as well maybe if he's still here. Aaron Lewis is a player I've liked since his early u18s days, but maybeabit soon for him.
If the kids get a chance in a team that's not a shambles some of them will push on. Look at the players teams like Liverpool and Everton have had appear as if from nowhere to become established players in the last 12 months.
If they're never backed by a brave manager we'll never get anyone coming through. | | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 17:33 - Dec 27 with 5047 views | Yossarian |
None of them. Clement would have used them but he wasn’t confident they would add nothing. His judgement now seems to be vindicated because paying what Jenkins was happy to pay for our summer signings looks ridiculously incompetent now.
Seriously, the recruitment and scouting department of this club has wasted millions and their judgement is so questionable and their performance so shockingly bad that they should be the first group to be collecting their P45s when we go down....correction to that, they should be gone today. |  |
| "Yossarian- the very sight of the name made him shudder.There were so many esses in it. It just had to be subversive" (Catch 22) |
| |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 17:43 - Dec 27 with 5019 views | jasper_T |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 17:33 - Dec 27 by Yossarian |
None of them. Clement would have used them but he wasn’t confident they would add nothing. His judgement now seems to be vindicated because paying what Jenkins was happy to pay for our summer signings looks ridiculously incompetent now.
Seriously, the recruitment and scouting department of this club has wasted millions and their judgement is so questionable and their performance so shockingly bad that they should be the first group to be collecting their P45s when we go down....correction to that, they should be gone today. |
Clement was an appalling judge of player ability. His selections were baffling.
Not sure how you've come to the conclusion that anything he did has been vindicated. | | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 17:57 - Dec 27 with 4994 views | icecoldjack |
Hmm.. difficult one this. Ben Davies came through when Laudrup saw potential, Brendan Rodgers perhaps didn't see the same thing ? Both good coaches but maybe saw things a bit different.
My knowledge of Ben s progress is sketchy truth be told, I remember him getting the call over other players like obeng to join the pre season tour. Maybe he was always destined for glory ?
Sometimes you need to take a chance on a player,especially at the swans where the crowd will always love a trier . |  | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 17:59 - Dec 27 with 4988 views | waynekerr55 |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 06:58 - Dec 27 by Jackfath |
I agree.
Some of the players who play for that side are robbing a living. Why would any professional want to play week in week out for that side? Surely you'd want to back yourself and move on to turn out for a div 1/div 2 side and build your rep.
It's far too comfortable there for them. Huge salaries for not doing too much at all. |
They'll be lucky to play non league. The u23 league is a shambles |  |
| |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 18:50 - Dec 27 with 4938 views | jasper_T |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 17:59 - Dec 27 by waynekerr55 |
They'll be lucky to play non league. The u23 league is a shambles |
Recent washouts are playing regular League One football. Ryan Hedges just got a Wales cap after we sold him.
Bournemouth are about to sign Rodon. | | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 19:02 - Dec 27 with 4918 views | paulv2k4 |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 18:50 - Dec 27 by jasper_T |
Recent washouts are playing regular League One football. Ryan Hedges just got a Wales cap after we sold him.
Bournemouth are about to sign Rodon. |
That's interesting to hear. Do you have a source? | | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 19:46 - Dec 27 with 4855 views | Treforys_Jack |
Clement used Fer instead of the U23 right back when Naughton was injured. Just saying. |  | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 20:07 - Dec 27 with 4840 views | Kilkennyjack |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 18:50 - Dec 27 by jasper_T |
Recent washouts are playing regular League One football. Ryan Hedges just got a Wales cap after we sold him.
Bournemouth are about to sign Rodon. |
But the unarguable truth is that since the Academy investment has gone in, then not a single meaningful player has been produced for our first team.
No ifs, no buts...... nobody since Ben in august 2012.
Thats the only measure. Shocking. | |
| Beware of the Risen People
|
| |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 20:12 - Dec 27 with 4825 views | jasper_T |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 19:46 - Dec 27 by Treforys_Jack |
Clement used Fer instead of the U23 right back when Naughton was injured. Just saying. |
Because the best u23 right back was shipped off to Boro where he started further down the pecking order than he was here.
Tyler Reid is a bit of a shithouse. | | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 20:14 - Dec 27 with 4820 views | jasper_T |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 20:07 - Dec 27 by Kilkennyjack |
But the unarguable truth is that since the Academy investment has gone in, then not a single meaningful player has been produced for our first team.
No ifs, no buts...... nobody since Ben in august 2012.
Thats the only measure. Shocking. |
That's a measure 15/20 Cat One academies would fail. | | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 20:17 - Dec 27 with 4811 views | skettyparkherbert |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 20:14 - Dec 27 by jasper_T |
That's a measure 15/20 Cat One academies would fail. |
Then to my way of thinking 15/20 cat 1 academies have failed and if that is the case hat are they all about then please enlighten us?? | | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 20:28 - Dec 27 with 4788 views | jasper_T |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 20:17 - Dec 27 by skettyparkherbert |
Then to my way of thinking 15/20 cat 1 academies have failed and if that is the case hat are they all about then please enlighten us?? |
Most of those academies are still profitable, either by selling players to clubs lower down the league, earning off compensation deals, or waiting for the one big payday.
You won't win if you don't play the game. | | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 20:43 - Dec 27 with 4764 views | Oldjack |
They play fast nice one touch football as a team ,that should be more that enough to beat the first team |  |
| Prosser the Tosser dwells on Phil's bum hole like a rusty old hemorrhoid ,fact
You Greedy Bastards Get Out Of OUR Club!
|
| |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 20:43 - Dec 27 with 4764 views | skettyparkherbert |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 20:28 - Dec 27 by jasper_T |
Most of those academies are still profitable, either by selling players to clubs lower down the league, earning off compensation deals, or waiting for the one big payday.
You won't win if you don't play the game. |
Thanks for the explanation, seems a bit complicated to me.
Can you tell me what profit, if any, the Swans Academy has made from any of the deals you mention because from what i hear the Academy players are also getting paid £100's of pounds a week too.
Eg, Mcburnie £8.5k a week, Joe Rodon £2.5k a week what does the academy bring in to cover even the wages alone? | | | |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 20:46 - Dec 27 with 4757 views | jasper_T |
| if our U23s played our first team... on 20:43 - Dec 27 by skettyparkherbert |
Thanks for the explanation, seems a bit complicated to me.
Can you tell me what profit, if any, the Swans Academy has made from any of the deals you mention because from what i hear the Academy players are also getting paid £100's of pounds a week too.
Eg, Mcburnie £8.5k a week, Joe Rodon £2.5k a week what does the academy bring in to cover even the wages alone? |
Ryan Hedges was bought for a few hundred thousand.
We've brought in loan fees for Gorre, Adam King, Fulton etc.
Our academy certainly hasn't turned a profit yet. The facilities were only finished a couple of years ago.
McBurnie's £8.5K looks better value than the £7.5m+ we've spent on Sanches, and the £50k a week Clucas gets. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
