Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
QPR master own downfall in City reality check — Report
Sunday, 18th Aug 2019 15:14 by Clive Whittingham

QPR suffered their first defeat of the season at Ashton Gate on Saturday, going down to a self-inflicted 2-0 loss to Bristol City.

A feeling of something big building, the rumble of something good brewing, the growing feeling that having decided to spend the summer throwing all the cards up in the air they might have miraculously landed just right for Queens Park Rangers. Yes, the demon hope has been back stalking the corridors of Loftus Road in the opening weeks of the 2019/20 season, and while it hasn’t been splatted stone dead by Saturday’s defeat at Bristol City it has been tempered rather.

QPR haven’t won at Ashton Gate in ten attempts, losing the last four. There’s been some horrors amongst them — Ian Holloway’s team beaten 2-0 despite playing against ten men for the majority of the game — and some scandalous con jobs — last season’s nonsense injury time penalty decision against Darnell Furlong still rankles. This latest setback, neatly continuing a pattern of losses that now reads 2-1, 2-0, 2-1, 2-0, mixed frustration and naivety in equal measure.

Frustration because, for so much of the game, and almost all of the first half, Rangers looked by far the more adept of the two teams. Down one wing they had Ebere Eze in luscious form, feasting on the soul of full back Jack Hunt with a mesmeric first half that started to kick into gear on six minutes when he glided past three men with ease and came within an inch of teeing up Jordan Hugoll for the first goal. Down the other, Andy Impey tribute act Bright Osayi-Samuel, much more basic and obvious with his approach but no less effective. He was the last link in a lovely chain on the half hour that saw Eze move the ball through Geoff Cameron to Osayi-Samuel who crossed for Hugill to head wide.

When Luke Amos robbed City of the ball high up the pitch it gave Hugill another chance which he blasted over and on a rare occasion when the hosts did return fire Benik Afobe found his path to Joe Lumley’s goal blocked inadvertently by Tommy Rowe who accidentally tackled his own man.

For all that though, it was City who took the lead ten before half time. There’d been a little warning sign a few minutes early when perennial scourge of QPR Andreas Weimann bundled his way through a crowd scene and Yoann Barbet had to make a good covering tackle, and Angel Rangel deliberately delaying a restart for a mandatory yellow card did suggest a slight swing in momentum. But in all honesty there was so little sign that the Robins might be about to take the lead that the 1,600 QPR fans behind the goal had actually been mocking Hunt in the build up for a first half performance that had seen Eze twist his blood without the ball and QPR frequently receive throw ins from his poor control with it. Those mocking ironic cheers rammed right back down the visitors’ throats by a Hunt cross which Hall half cleared and summer signing Adam Nagy volleyed brilliantly, first time, into the bottom corner for 1-0. Tough on QPR, but just rewards for Nagy who looked very assured in an otherwise below-par home team prior to is withdrawal through injury at half time.

Osayi-Samuel was perhaps fortunate when his angry reaction to being wrestled away from play off the ball in first half injury time only brought a yellow card when he appeared to lift his knee to Rowe who, as is just pathetically accepted as the norm in our sport now, made an absolute meal of it having caused the situation himself in the first place. Not the first or last time referee Robert Jones had shown leniency — no yellow card for Geoff Cameron for a deliberate hack at Kasey Palmer to interrupt a dangerous counter attack, nor for Rowe at the start of the second half when he pulled Osayi-Samuel’s shirt to prevent him from escaping down the line for the umpteenth time in the game. When the card did come out, for the hapless Hunt, it actually looked like Osayi-Samuel had dived to win the free kick that caused it. No matter, Yoann Barbet stuck the resulting free kick, and several other set pieces besides, straight into the wall. Wastefulness was becoming a bit of a theme.

The naivety reared its ugly head on the hour. QPR had started the second half really well. They should have equalised immediately when Osayi-Samuel crossed low to the near post and Hugill shot over from close range. Then the loaned West Ham forward got a flicked header to corner diverted into his path by Grant Hall but home keeper Daniel Bentley adjusted his feet and body well and tipped the ball over the bar. It felt positive, it felt like an equaliser was coming, Rangers felt like the better team again after a little post-first-goal wobble. Ilias Chair, so impressive against City in the cup during the week, was summoned from the bench to add to the goal threat and we looked forward to a big last third of the game with the super hoops laying siege to the City goal.

Instead, Mark Warburton’s team self-immolated. Faced with a routine throw in down in the right back spot, Angel Rangel spurned convention and hurled a dangerous bouncing bomb into his own area rather than just going down the line as he and everybody else that’s ever played the sport has done in that situation ever since the game was invented. It looked a catastrophe waiting to happen, gaining nothing for the team even if it went according to plan, being clever for clever’s sake, and one spaffed header from Barbet and a wild swing and miss at the ball from Joe Lumley later it was 2-0 as Afobe volleyed into the empty net. That hard won recovery from the first goal, that momentum built up at the start of the second half, the Chair substitution — all of it blown up because it’s beneath us now to throw a ball down the line and compete for a header on halfway. Rangel blamed Barbet, Barbet blamed Lumley, Lumley blamed Rangel. Between the three of them they’d cost us the game.

Thereafter City looked comfortable. That might have changed had Chair’s shot on the run squeezed over the line after being fumbled by Bentley but the former Brentford man sat on the ball before it ran away from him. Kane came on for Rangel and, again, added attacking impetus down his side and prevented City from doubling up on Osayi-Samuel — we really need to get to a point where Kane is starting games ahead of the Spaniard as quickly as possible. But Nahki Wells was less effective in replacing the fading Eze, barely touching the ball at all in his half hour of action.

The confidence QPR came into the game with seemed to drain away awfully quickly at 2-0, and they were very swift to deviate away from the plan and style of play that has served them well in the opening few games. Warburton and Hugill were both repeatedly seen making exaggerated ‘calm down’ gestures to panicked players in hooped tops. When Hall rushed a clearance straight to the nearest City man a cross into the box looked destined for 3-0 when substitute Han Noah Massengo headed for goal but it deflected away at the last minute. As he had done from the start in the cup during the week, the summer recruit from Monaco looks some player. Weimann also thought he’d got his usual goal against us ten from time, but he’d pretty clearly punched the ball in past Joe Lumley and was rightly booked. The goal chalked off.

It was, in the end, a disappointing afternoon. The sort of performance we’ve taken the piss out of Brentford for over recent years — all tips and taps and silk and smooth in the middle third, but not enough meat on the bones in either penalty box. Rangers didn’t carry enough goal threat (a problem that I think risks becoming chronic with this team) at one end, and made some stupidly simple mistakes at the other. Nearly 60% of the possession, 15 shots to the hosts’ nine, but only two on target and no goals scored.

All of the talk on the train down in the morning had been about whether Warburton would keep faith with Josh Scowen at ‘ten’ for his extra experience and defensive ability in a difficult away game, or throw caution to the wind and reward Chair for his midweek heroics with a start against the team he tormented on Tuesday. With Scowen out injured, I’m not entirely sure what Man City’s Matt Smith did to justify leaping over Chair in the queue for that spot, or really what he contributed to the performance here, particularly in the attacking third.

But, in the same way it was a bit daft to be getting carried away with taking four points from what look like poor Stoke and Huddersfield teams — the more I see of the Terriers the worse that draw last week looks — so it would be foolish to start throwing babies and bath water about after an away loss at a team many fancy for a promotion push this season. This much changed QPR team could still turn out to be anything at all, and we’ll know more after two home games this week against a Swansea team that play a similar style to our own and a Wigan side that lost 16 times on the road last season and are fancied for a relegation scrap this.

Links >>> Ratings and Reports >>> Message Board Match Thread

Bristol City: Bentley 6; Kalas 6, Baker 6, Moore 6; Hunt 4 (Pereira 58, 6), Brownhill 6, Nagy 7 (Massengo 46, 7) Rowe 6; Palmer 5 (Eliasson 71, 6), Weimann 6; Afobe 6

Subs not used: Diedhiou, Gilmartin, Szmodics, Semenyo

Goals: Nagy 35 (unassisted), Afobe 59 (assisted Weimann)

Bookings: Hunt 55 (foul), Weimann 79 (deliberate handball)

QPR: Lumley 5; Rangel 5 (Kane 65, 6), Hall 6, Barbet 6, Manning 6; Cameron 6, Amos 6; Osayi-Samuel 7, Smith 5 (Chair 59, 6), Eze 6 (Wells 65, 5); Hugill 5

Subs not used: Pugh, Ball, Kelly, Leistner

Cards: Rangel 34 (kicking ball away), Osayi Samuel 45+3 (retaliation)

QPR Star Man — Bright Osayi-Samuel 7 Terrorised City all afternoon and should really have an assist to his name but for Hugill’s bad miss at the start of the second half.

Referee — Rob Jones (Merseyside) 7 There does seem to be a real effort from the Championship referees so far this season to keep their cards in their pocket wherever possible. Cameron and Rowe were both allowed off with a warning for fouls in the early stages of the second half that used to be considered mandatory. This calm, lenient approach thankfully extended to Osayi-Samuel’s temper tantrum in first half injury time, though I have always hated the way retaliation in football is treated as a much more heinous offence than the, on this occasion blatant and deliberate, foul play that caused it. Overall, pretty good, with the big decisions — Osayi–Samuel red card, Weimann handball, correct.

Attendance — 21,654 (1,613 QPR) Big following from West London, and not too much adverse reaction to a poor result and fading second half performance from where we were sitting. Love how they’ve developed this stadium.

The Twitter/Instagram @loftforwords

Pictures, if they’d ever bloody take any of our games — Action Images

Action Images



Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.



QPRski added 15:36 - Aug 18
A very objective and extremely timely report.

Let’s check the mood after the next two home games this week.
0

QPRski added 15:36 - Aug 18
A very objective and extremely timely report.

Let’s check the mood after the next two home games this week.
1

BazzaInTheLoft added 17:08 - Aug 18
‘Andy Impey Tribute Act’

10/10
2

ridethewave added 17:20 - Aug 18
Cheers for the report, Clive. Just going to copy and paste what I wrote on the match thread, as I think it very true even after the disappointment of yesterday has subsided:

Rangel was more at fault for that then Lumley in my opinion, though not discounting how awful it was from him too. An experienced player like Rangel making a throw on like that? Terrible.

What do I know, but I was so surprised when I saw Rangel on the team sheet, thought he looked the weak point in the first half, sure enough got himself booked early on, and then produced that throw on. Manager must have had a damn good excuse for not playing Kane.

So frustrating, but can’t say we deserved much, we created nothing up front, and I see that being the worry for us this season.
0

ridethewave added 17:24 - Aug 18
Also, on reflection, I think we’ve seen enough mistakes from Lumley now to know he’s not going to be good enough for a team that wants to push on (I assume that’s what we’ll want to do eventually?). We’ve seen this with Green, we know there’s no hope of achieving much when you can always rely on your keeper for a big mistake.
-2

062259 added 21:03 - Aug 18
42 points from safety
2

Patrick added 22:15 - Aug 18
So. Should we apply for membership of the Justice League along with you know who? And is Hugill a donkey? Only asking.
0

Myke added 00:07 - Aug 19
Cheers Clive. Following the game on BBC it sounded like we huffed and puffed without much end product , which is borne out by your match report. Given a choice of which of the 2 games I would rather win I would have chosen the mid-week game. Especially with a home draw against Portsmouth in the next round. We're (probably) not going to win the League Cup, but we are (almost certainly) not going to get promoted to the Prem so another little cup run would be fun . On a more serious note we have now conceded 7 goals in 4 games so no sign of us solving that particular malaise, despite using a mixture of new and old personnel. Much work to be done, but we knew that before the game anyway
0

westberksr added 07:46 - Aug 19
great report Clive

with the luck of the bounce this result could have been very different; but having missed the previous matches due to holiday I was quietly encouraged by the team shape & play.

Selection wise, post match, I totally agree, but having not seen the previous matches had to go with the flow. Rangel's throw was atrocious and it was then just a collection of fukk ups.

Given the number of new players & the 'bedding in' time I wasn't too disheartened overall.

Thanks for meeting up with the ticket too
0

DesertBoot added 10:19 - Aug 19
Thanks for the report Clive. The Stoke and Huddersfield results have now been put into perspective and here we made stupid mistakes and weren't convincing at all in front of goal - sounds familiar but new personnel and a proper manager can put that right.
Two home games back to back to continue the work in progress.
0

SimonJames added 14:22 - Aug 19
"...though I have always hated the way retaliation in football is treated as a much more heinous offence than the... foul play that caused it"
Although sadly in rugby union (I'm not sure about league) they're now frowning on retaliatory fistycuffs.
0

Myke added 16:12 - Aug 19
I see that despite having not having the best of games, Smithies up to his penalty saving tricks
0

TacticalR added 22:03 - Aug 19
Thanks for your report.

We couldn't score when we had the upper hand (that's why we lost), then Nagy scored a quality goal, then we self-destructed.
0


You need to login in order to post your comments

Blogs 31 bloggers

Knees-up Mother Brown #22 by wessex_exile

Bolton Wanderers Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2024