| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 16:45 - Dec 1 with 1542 views | PinnerPaul |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 13:22 - Dec 1 by LongsufferingR |
Re the Dunne penalty shout, they showed another angle on TV where it looked to me like they both had big handfuls of each other's shirts, so I didn't get too annoyed about it at the time, and thankfully made no difference in the end anyway. |
Yep and the 'push' on Chair - really? Just put his hand on his back - that's not a push.
Agree with Clive about the 'missing' Derby yellow 1st half but otherwise ref was good - nothing much to ref, but again 6 incredibly harsh - 4 points off for it being an easy game and one missed yellow? |  | |  |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 17:11 - Dec 1 with 1481 views | Northernr |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 16:45 - Dec 1 by PinnerPaul |
Yep and the 'push' on Chair - really? Just put his hand on his back - that's not a push.
Agree with Clive about the 'missing' Derby yellow 1st half but otherwise ref was good - nothing much to ref, but again 6 incredibly harsh - 4 points off for it being an easy game and one missed yellow? |
I thought it was a penalty on Dunne, so one off from a 7. |  | | |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 17:14 - Dec 1 with 1472 views | BrianMcCarthy |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 16:45 - Dec 1 by PinnerPaul |
Yep and the 'push' on Chair - really? Just put his hand on his back - that's not a push.
Agree with Clive about the 'missing' Derby yellow 1st half but otherwise ref was good - nothing much to ref, but again 6 incredibly harsh - 4 points off for it being an easy game and one missed yellow? |
I thought it was a peno, Paul.
He flew into the net. Definite push.
I also thought the one on Dunne was a peno at the time, but was obviously wrong on that one. |  |
| |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 17:49 - Dec 1 with 1411 views | PinnerPaul |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 17:11 - Dec 1 by Northernr |
I thought it was a penalty on Dunne, so one off from a 7. |
Only if we ignore the fact that Dunne had hold of oppo shirt for exactly the same amount of time minus 0.1 seconds!
Doesn't matter, we won and no major errors from the officials (IMHO)  | | | |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 17:53 - Dec 1 with 1405 views | PinnerPaul |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 17:14 - Dec 1 by BrianMcCarthy |
I thought it was a peno, Paul.
He flew into the net. Definite push.
I also thought the one on Dunne was a peno at the time, but was obviously wrong on that one. |
Fair enough - not for me, but its all opinions in the end.
He was pretty consistent ("Consistently wrong" - be quiet at the back - as Clive would say) as he didn't penalise Charlie for a push in the 1st half - about our only chance that.
Anyway back to the football, I thought it was a pretty poor game and only average at best from us, apart from the two wonderful goals. | | | |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 18:36 - Dec 1 with 1358 views | BrianMcCarthy |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 17:53 - Dec 1 by PinnerPaul |
Fair enough - not for me, but its all opinions in the end.
He was pretty consistent ("Consistently wrong" - be quiet at the back - as Clive would say) as he didn't penalise Charlie for a push in the 1st half - about our only chance that.
Anyway back to the football, I thought it was a pretty poor game and only average at best from us, apart from the two wonderful goals. |
All opinions, as you say.
I thought we were slightly below par in our passing and I thought we really missed Dykes' energy, but it's a sign of how good we are now that we were still comfortably the better team. | |
| |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 18:46 - Dec 1 with 1345 views | Northernr |
On the marking though, we never give 10s, Mark Clattenburg Wigan play-off semi final always springs to mind as one of the best refereeing performances I've ever seen live, I think I gave that a 9. We've given some 8s, but can we say Jeremy was really that close to Clattenburg the other night?
I always mark harsh anyway, 6 is about right. Maybe a 7 if you're adament Dunne wasn't a penalty, and that weird thing in the first half where Adomah got fouled and fouled again weren't actually fouls at all, and missing a pretty obvious pull back yellow etc etc. | | | |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 19:26 - Dec 1 with 1303 views | OldPedro |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 18:46 - Dec 1 by Northernr |
On the marking though, we never give 10s, Mark Clattenburg Wigan play-off semi final always springs to mind as one of the best refereeing performances I've ever seen live, I think I gave that a 9. We've given some 8s, but can we say Jeremy was really that close to Clattenburg the other night?
I always mark harsh anyway, 6 is about right. Maybe a 7 if you're adament Dunne wasn't a penalty, and that weird thing in the first half where Adomah got fouled and fouled again weren't actually fouls at all, and missing a pretty obvious pull back yellow etc etc. |
I thought the ref was poor for both sides - almost seemed to just ignore lots of challenges from both sides. Probably should have issued 2 or 3 yellow cards - until he booked Gray, I genuinely thought he had forgotten to bring them! |  |
| Extra mature cheddar......a simple cheese for a simple man |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 20:05 - Dec 1 with 1256 views | Lanhoop |
One thing I'd add about the penalty is that even if you didn't give for the pull on Dunne, you'd have to give it for what Byrne is doing to Dickie right next to them.
I'm hoping Dickie got the chance to take a morning after pill otherwise he'll be taking some maternity leave at the start of next season. | | | |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 22:28 - Dec 1 with 1088 views | Antti_Heinola |
I thought the ref was very decent, but if anyone thinks that yank on Dunne wasn’t a penalty they shouldn’t be allowed to own a whistle, let alone use one on a pitch. There’s pushing and pulling off the ball from corners, which we have to accept goes on, and then there’s yanking someone back at the moment they’re about to score. I actually don’t have a problem with the ref missing it as it’s tough in a 6 yard box melee, but retrospectively, come on, that is a pen all day long, I don’t care what happened before. If we’re saying Dykes’ foul at Boro was a pen - and I had no problem at all with that decision - this was far, far more deserving. (Missing Austin’s blatant push first half was a far bigger mistake, although maybe he would have blown had it gone in). |  |
| |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 22:31 - Dec 1 with 1080 views | Dorse |
#announceravel
... is a lazy fat bastard. |  |
| 'What do we want? We don't know! When do we want it? Now!' |
| |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 22:41 - Dec 1 with 1061 views | kensalriser |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 22:31 - Dec 1 by Dorse |
#announceravel
... is a lazy fat bastard. |
I think that's more #denounceravel. |  |
| |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 22:42 - Dec 1 with 1060 views | Superhoop83 |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 22:31 - Dec 1 by Dorse |
#announceravel
... is a lazy fat bastard. |
#denounceravel
The Invisible Man would have been more visible. |  |
| |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 23:32 - Dec 1 with 1015 views | toboboly |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 22:28 - Dec 1 by Antti_Heinola |
I thought the ref was very decent, but if anyone thinks that yank on Dunne wasn’t a penalty they shouldn’t be allowed to own a whistle, let alone use one on a pitch. There’s pushing and pulling off the ball from corners, which we have to accept goes on, and then there’s yanking someone back at the moment they’re about to score. I actually don’t have a problem with the ref missing it as it’s tough in a 6 yard box melee, but retrospectively, come on, that is a pen all day long, I don’t care what happened before. If we’re saying Dykes’ foul at Boro was a pen - and I had no problem at all with that decision - this was far, far more deserving. (Missing Austin’s blatant push first half was a far bigger mistake, although maybe he would have blown had it gone in). |
The replay showed the ref with an unobstructed view of the whole thing |  |
| Sexy Asian dwarves wanted. |
| |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 12:41 - Dec 2 with 840 views | PinnerPaul |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 18:46 - Dec 1 by Northernr |
On the marking though, we never give 10s, Mark Clattenburg Wigan play-off semi final always springs to mind as one of the best refereeing performances I've ever seen live, I think I gave that a 9. We've given some 8s, but can we say Jeremy was really that close to Clattenburg the other night?
I always mark harsh anyway, 6 is about right. Maybe a 7 if you're adament Dunne wasn't a penalty, and that weird thing in the first half where Adomah got fouled and fouled again weren't actually fouls at all, and missing a pretty obvious pull back yellow etc etc. |
TBF Clive, that is all good - for some reason I WAS a bit grumpy ref wise yesterday - didn't have a very enjoyable game Monday night - U23s, who are usually pretty well behaved, constantly moaning about EVERYTHING - eventually ref gave up and gave one a sin bin.
Actual marking for promotion purposes, DOES actually take into account the ease of the match to referee - so for an easy match, a referee could be faultless yet still only get 70 -73 (Out of 100) - something like that.
Agree completely about Clattenburg - high pressure, fast game with one or two KMIs to call - all correct and positioning spot on all night. | | | |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 12:44 - Dec 2 with 828 views | PinnerPaul |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 22:28 - Dec 1 by Antti_Heinola |
I thought the ref was very decent, but if anyone thinks that yank on Dunne wasn’t a penalty they shouldn’t be allowed to own a whistle, let alone use one on a pitch. There’s pushing and pulling off the ball from corners, which we have to accept goes on, and then there’s yanking someone back at the moment they’re about to score. I actually don’t have a problem with the ref missing it as it’s tough in a 6 yard box melee, but retrospectively, come on, that is a pen all day long, I don’t care what happened before. If we’re saying Dykes’ foul at Boro was a pen - and I had no problem at all with that decision - this was far, far more deserving. (Missing Austin’s blatant push first half was a far bigger mistake, although maybe he would have blown had it gone in). |
Absolutely see your point, but really you're saying, in effect, OK for attackers to do the pulling/shirt tugging but not the defenders.
You admit that Dunne WAS holding the other guy's shirt - its a difficult 'sell' as a ref to say you didn't see that but DID see/penalise the defender? | | | |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 13:19 - Dec 2 with 793 views | LazyFan |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 18:46 - Dec 1 by Northernr |
On the marking though, we never give 10s, Mark Clattenburg Wigan play-off semi final always springs to mind as one of the best refereeing performances I've ever seen live, I think I gave that a 9. We've given some 8s, but can we say Jeremy was really that close to Clattenburg the other night?
I always mark harsh anyway, 6 is about right. Maybe a 7 if you're adament Dunne wasn't a penalty, and that weird thing in the first half where Adomah got fouled and fouled again weren't actually fouls at all, and missing a pretty obvious pull back yellow etc etc. |
What did you give the ref that gave us a last min penalty against Millwall that Wilson converted all those many years ago?
Surely the ref has some guts giving a last min penalty against the baying hordes the Marxist Hunters? |  |
| |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 13:20 - Dec 2 with 786 views | Northernr |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 13:19 - Dec 2 by LazyFan |
What did you give the ref that gave us a last min penalty against Millwall that Wilson converted all those many years ago?
Surely the ref has some guts giving a last min penalty against the baying hordes the Marxist Hunters? |
I was 10  | | | |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 13:27 - Dec 2 with 768 views | toboboly |
| Stop me if you've heard this one before - Report on 13:20 - Dec 2 by Northernr |
I was 10 |
So you'd give yourself a 10????
Hypocrite. | |
| Sexy Asian dwarves wanted. |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
