| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights 14:12 - Jan 2 with 6441 views | MHall963 |
Just watched the video highlights on dale player from yesterday's game. My thoughts are that we are lucky to have not got 2, possibly 3 suspensions. These thoughts are only based on the highlights though. For the first, Scotty hogan seemed to headbutt or at least shove the scunny player with his head, as a result I feel he may have got away with this. For the second incident, this being the rose yellow, we all know how that went, so there's the second yellow although it did look as though rose got something on the ball. Then lastly, as scunnys attacker was through on goal, olly had a little tug at him, but then thought better of it and let go, it might've been a different story had he gone down. Anyway just my thoughts and having watched the highlights. Onwards and upwards, let's look forward to Leeds now. Up the dale! |  | | |  |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 14:25 - Jan 2 with 4899 views | Mass_Debater |
We all saw the Hogan incident at the time. He was lucky.
Clear second foul by Rose. | | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 17:34 - Jan 2 with 4712 views | dale4ever |
Those highlights for me show how lucky hogan was, but we all knew that anyway! But Rose was unlucky he clearly got the ball it goes the opposite direction! | | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:00 - Jan 2 with 4653 views | True_Blue2 |
Those two saves from Slocombe looked good at the time, but the highlights show just how top drawer they were. |  | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:02 - Jan 2 with 4648 views | Mass_Debater |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 17:34 - Jan 2 by dale4ever |
Those highlights for me show how lucky hogan was, but we all knew that anyway! But Rose was unlucky he clearly got the ball it goes the opposite direction! |
No he didn't. | | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:09 - Jan 2 with 4611 views | dale4ever |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:02 - Jan 2 by Mass_Debater |
No he didn't. |
Are you blind? | | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:12 - Jan 2 with 4600 views | Mass_Debater |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:09 - Jan 2 by dale4ever |
Are you blind? |
No.
Why are you always so aggressive with people who have a different opinion? [Post edited 2 Jan 2014 18:13]
| | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:13 - Jan 2 with 4598 views | dale4ever |
Wasn't aggressive just don't understand how you can't see the ball travelling back in the opposite direction it didn't do it on it's own? | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:17 - Jan 2 with 4582 views | Mass_Debater |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:13 - Jan 2 by dale4ever |
Wasn't aggressive just don't understand how you can't see the ball travelling back in the opposite direction it didn't do it on it's own? |
Their player knocked it back when he checked back, in my opinion.
And if you aren't aggressive, why not just say "I don't agree?" instead of "Are you blind?". This isn't the L2 forum. [Post edited 2 Jan 2014 18:18]
| | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:26 - Jan 2 with 4539 views | dale4ever |
Ok | | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:38 - Jan 2 with 4491 views | firgrovedale51 |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:17 - Jan 2 by Mass_Debater |
Their player knocked it back when he checked back, in my opinion.
And if you aren't aggressive, why not just say "I don't agree?" instead of "Are you blind?". This isn't the L2 forum. [Post edited 2 Jan 2014 18:18]
|
Just watched the replay and Rose definitely played the ball . | | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:41 - Jan 2 with 4486 views | maybee |
Looks like 2 fantastic saves by their keeper changed the game.
Also looks like Hogan should have been sent off.
Rose too fully deserving of a second yellow for that challenge. Doesn't show the first foul, but no-one seems to be arguing about that.
Shame that Rose now misses the Leeds game, but it looks like the ref got it spot on. |  | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:57 - Jan 2 with 4436 views | davidk95 |
I can't decide why the referee hasn't sent hogan off. He's in front of the incident and doesn't take much time to think, very very lucky. | | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 18:59 - Jan 2 with 4429 views | 442Dale |
It's not 100%, but their player did look to stop his run with Rose catching him. Think it's the perfect example of taking a bit of time at games and not automatically blaming the ref who has to make a decision very quickly. Or listening to commentary and forming an opinion on that! More often than not this season it has shown that the refs have got it right.
Can't understand Hogan's reaction at all. He's lucky. Good point in original post about Lancashire not pulling down their man, you could almost see him thinking twice about it. |  |
| |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 19:04 - Jan 2 with 4410 views | dingdangblue |
Slocombe 1st save - World class.
Hogan incident - Red card.
Slocombe 2nd save - Cummins shoudve buried it.
Rose incident - definite foul and 2nd yellow. |  |
| |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 19:09 - Jan 2 with 4404 views | firgrovedale51 |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 19:04 - Jan 2 by dingdangblue |
Slocombe 1st save - World class.
Hogan incident - Red card.
Slocombe 2nd save - Cummins shoudve buried it.
Rose incident - definite foul and 2nd yellow. |
Rose played the ball definately | | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 19:12 - Jan 2 with 4388 views | 442Dale |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 19:04 - Jan 2 by dingdangblue |
Slocombe 1st save - World class.
Hogan incident - Red card.
Slocombe 2nd save - Cummins shoudve buried it.
Rose incident - definite foul and 2nd yellow. |
Seeing the second save, I'm in agreement. Great save but the header was near enough to him to give Slocombe a chance.
Rose is not definite one way or another, and I've slowed it down a few times! What is possible to say is that the ref was nearer than the camera and gave decision as he saw fit, and it's not one anyone can be certain enough to argue with. | |
| |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 19:12 - Jan 2 with 4383 views | Mass_Debater |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 19:09 - Jan 2 by firgrovedale51 |
Rose played the ball definately |
There's nothing definite about it. | | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 19:21 - Jan 2 with 4352 views | SalwaDale |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 19:12 - Jan 2 by 442Dale |
Seeing the second save, I'm in agreement. Great save but the header was near enough to him to give Slocombe a chance.
Rose is not definite one way or another, and I've slowed it down a few times! What is possible to say is that the ref was nearer than the camera and gave decision as he saw fit, and it's not one anyone can be certain enough to argue with. |
But your last paragraph is the reason why it shouldn't have resulted in a red card, albeit from a second yellow.
The more I think, the ref did have a stinker yesterday, basically because he let so much go early on. Once Hogan had let his frustration get the better of him, the ref seemed to realise he had let the game get away from him and then seemed keen to re-assert his control. Had Hogan not done the ridiculous body charge, we'd be discussing either a great comeback or commending Scunthorpe on keeping us out.
Not saying Scunthorpe were dirty or divers, but they were canny and certainly had a bit more game nouse than some of our players. Yesterday could be a very important lesson for Hogan. |  |
| |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 19:28 - Jan 2 with 4334 views | 442Dale |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 19:21 - Jan 2 by SalwaDale |
But your last paragraph is the reason why it shouldn't have resulted in a red card, albeit from a second yellow.
The more I think, the ref did have a stinker yesterday, basically because he let so much go early on. Once Hogan had let his frustration get the better of him, the ref seemed to realise he had let the game get away from him and then seemed keen to re-assert his control. Had Hogan not done the ridiculous body charge, we'd be discussing either a great comeback or commending Scunthorpe on keeping us out.
Not saying Scunthorpe were dirty or divers, but they were canny and certainly had a bit more game nouse than some of our players. Yesterday could be a very important lesson for Hogan. |
Yeah the ref did seem to want to make t obvious he was in charge after that incident, but still don't think he got a lot wrong while doing that. It was just unnecessary.
The second yellow: Think what I was trying to say is that we'll have to go with the ref's decision because he had a better view. It might have been obvious to him that it was a booking. | |
| |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 20:32 - Jan 2 with 4228 views | dingdangblue |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 19:28 - Jan 2 by 442Dale |
Yeah the ref did seem to want to make t obvious he was in charge after that incident, but still don't think he got a lot wrong while doing that. It was just unnecessary.
The second yellow: Think what I was trying to say is that we'll have to go with the ref's decision because he had a better view. It might have been obvious to him that it was a booking. |
For me their guy has checked his run knowing Rose is bearing down on him. I think from the angle Rose challenges him if he had got the ball it would have headed towards Lillis goal. Clever play really, most probably knowing Rose had been booked already. | |
| |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 20:51 - Jan 2 with 4195 views | 49thseason |
I think its time the coaches had a word with Cummins about heading downwards, there have been a coupls of instances where he has tried to head into the roof of the net and been saved by the keeper, a downwards header onto the goal line is almost unstoppable. |  | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 20:58 - Jan 2 with 4175 views | Mass_Debater |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 20:32 - Jan 2 by dingdangblue |
For me their guy has checked his run knowing Rose is bearing down on him. I think from the angle Rose challenges him if he had got the ball it would have headed towards Lillis goal. Clever play really, most probably knowing Rose had been booked already. |
I doubt their player, who had just come on as a sub, could compute that fact in the millisecond he had available to him when Rose suddenly appeared. | | | |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 21:16 - Jan 2 with 4145 views | dingdangblue |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 20:58 - Jan 2 by Mass_Debater |
I doubt their player, who had just come on as a sub, could compute that fact in the millisecond he had available to him when Rose suddenly appeared. |
With nearly half of our outfield players on a yellow there was a decent chance! :-/ | |
| |
| Rochdale v Scunthorpe highlights on 21:27 - Jan 2 with 4118 views | sandylaner1 |
wasn't at game, not gonna watch highlights
thoughts fully on the leeds game now  |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
